Netzneutralitätstate of the debate

#DNP13, Thomas Lohninger, www.socialhack.eu

Wednesday, September 18, 13

Wednesday, September 18, 13

Wednesday, September 18, 13

Wednesday, September 18, 13

Kampagne

• 2 wöchentliche interne Arbeitstreffen

• 16 externe Veranstaltungen

• 3 Papers

• 22 Medienberichte

Wednesday, September 18, 13

Wednesday, September 18, 13

Sep 2012

Sep 2013Wednesday, September 18, 13

http://netneutralitymap.org/oneyear/Wednesday, September 18, 13

unsernetz.at/links/berec-eu-violations/Wednesday, September 18, 13

Best EffortInternet

Managed/Specialised

Services

Transport-dienstklassen

Wednesday, September 18, 13

Wednesday, September 18, 13

Wednesday, September 18, 13

Wednesday, September 18, 13

http://www.t-mobile.at/pdf/Deezer_unlimited_Music.pdf

Wednesday, September 18, 13

Wednesday, September 18, 13

Stakeholder

Wednesday, September 18, 13

Wahlmonitor.at

Wednesday, September 18, 13

Wednesday, September 18, 13

Wednesday, September 18, 13

Wednesday, September 18, 13

Wednesday, September 18, 13

Wednesday, September 18, 13

Positionspapier

1. Netzneutralität als Grundsatz

2. Abweichungen nur mit ausreichender Begründung

3. Transparenz

4. Keine Qualitätsverschlechterung

5. Angebote ohne Differenzierung als Standardprodukt

6. Kein Blocking oder Degrading

7. Keine exklusive Differenzierung

Wednesday, September 18, 13

EU Verordnung

Wednesday, September 18, 13

Meta

• extrem knapper Zeitplan

• handwerklich schlecht

• ETICS Wunschliste (FTW)

Wednesday, September 18, 13

single market

Wednesday, September 18, 13

RoamingNetzneutralität

Wednesday, September 18, 13

Transparenz

+Max/Min/Avg Bandbreiten

+Speed-Tests

+Stauvermeidung

- Marktsituation

Wednesday, September 18, 13

ISP = Hilfssheriff

• Verbrechensbekämpfung und Verhinderung

• 23.5.a “ implement a legislative provision or a court order, or prevent or impede serious crimes;”

• Informationspflicht

• 25.4.a “the most common uses of electronic communications services to engage in unlawful activities or to disseminate harmful content, particularly where it may prejudice respect for the rights and freedoms of others, including infringements of data protection rights, copyright and related rights, and their legal consequences“

Wednesday, September 18, 13

specialised services

Wednesday, September 18, 13

Slowenien

“Dienstleistungen der Netzbetreiber und Internet- Zugangsanbietern sollten nicht auf Anwendungen oder Diensten basieren, die über Internetzugangs- dienste

angeboten oder genutzt werden.”

Synopse der Gesetze zur Netzneutralität; https://unsernetz.at/files/Synopsis_CL_NL_SL.pdf

Wednesday, September 18, 13

Specialised services are electronic communications services that are provided

and operated within closed electronic communications networks using the Internet

Protocol. These networks rely on strict admission control and they are often optimised for specific applications based on extensive use of traffic management in order to ensure adequate service characteristics. …

BEREC

BEREC: Guidelines for Quality of Service in the scope of Net Neutrality; 3.3 Definition of basic concepts

Wednesday, September 18, 13

EU Kommission

• everything goes, but…

• “substantially impair the general quality of internet access services. ”

• “not marketed or widely used as a substitute for internet access service;"

recital (50) & Article 2.15 Wednesday, September 18, 13

Wednesday, September 18, 13

“There is still some confusion about net neutrality. That is not really the definition that I have on the net neutrality. The core

issue is whether internet access providers or network operators should be able to exercise control or limit users’ access to any content. For me, when that is done for commercially motivated reasons, that is absolutely a no-go. Only when security issues or when spam is involved to name just two – there is a list of these – but not for commercially motivated reasons. Then it is not net

neutrality.”

Wednesday, September 18, 13

http://www.europarl.europa.eu/hearings/static/commissioners/cre/kroes.pdf

Wednesday, September 18, 13

Was tun! Aber was?

• EU Wahlkampf

• mitmachen

• spenden

Wednesday, September 18, 13

2. L

esun

g

3. L

esun

g

verab

schiedetes Gesetz

1. L

esun

g

Vorschlag für Rechtsakt

gemeinsamer Standpunkt

geänderter gemeinsamer Standpunkt

Stellungnahmegemeinsamer Entwurf

akzeptiert Rechtsakt oder ändert ab billigt gem. Standpunkt

formuliert Stellungnahme

berät über Änderungswünsche des Parlaments

ändert Kommissions- oder Parlamentsentwurf

Rat der Europäischen Union

Vermittlungsausschuss

Europäische Kommission

Europäisches Parlament

Europäische GesetzgebungAm Beispiel des ordentlichen Gesetzgebungsverfahrens

Lizenz: Creative Commons by-nc-nd/3.0/deBundeszentrale für politische Bildung, 2010, www.bpb.de

Wednesday, September 18, 13

Danke

Fragen, Kommentare, Whistleblowing…

thomas.lohninger@netzfreiheit.org

Wednesday, September 18, 13