+ All Categories
Home > Documents > 東京工業大学shioura/papers/quadML.pdf! " # $&%(' )+*,' -.)0/.$ 1 $&2 3547698;:&)&= 8@? = 8A)&'...

東京工業大学shioura/papers/quadML.pdf! " # $&%(' )+*,' -.)0/.$ 1 $&2 3547698;:&)&= 8@? = 8A)&'...

Date post: 24-Jan-2021
Category:
Upload: others
View: 1 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
27
Transcript
Page 1: 東京工業大学shioura/papers/quadML.pdf! " # $&%(' )+*,' -.)0/.$ 1 $&2 3547698;:&)&= 8@? = 8A)&' ->$CB DFEHG;I>J>KLI>MONQPSRUT>VWV.XYVAZ []\!ZWV>G!^ I>MO_`V>\FPaRb_cNb\aRdN

�������������� � �� ���������� ����� ���� ���������� ����� ���!����"

#�$&%('�)+*,'�-.)0/.$�1�$&2�3547698;:&)&<>=�8@?�=�8A)&'�->$CBDFEHG;I>J>KLI>MONQPSRUT>VWV.XYVAZ�[]\!ZWV>G!^�I>MO_`V>\FPaRb_cNb\aRdN�I>\aJfeSNdRbT>\aV>XgVWhbikjmln\S_cobNUG!pd_`MOiQVAZ�eSV>qbikV.j

eaV.qUirV�s>s>t>u;v>w>x.w>jzy{I}|~I.\a�9I>\SJ��z���9P0e��Hj�y~P�e0j�eaV>qbirV>j�y{I}|~I>\� EHGAI.J>KLI>MONQPaRbT>VWV>X�VAZ�[]\�ZUV>G!^�I>MO_cV.\FPaRU_`NU\SRdNUp�j�eaV.T>V>qUK+l�\a_cobNUG!pd_`MOirj�PaNU\aJ.I>_9�>v.�>uAv.x(�}�>j

y{I}|~I.\

���0�W�W�k�a�>��&�S���;�����;���S�]���S� ¢¡d�;���{£���¤�¥ �§¦©¨!��ª¬«m¡d�;���{£���¤�¥ �§¦­¨!®¯��¥ �{�]®¯�nª�°��;�.ª�±~¦²«Q°a®¯���U¨�³]´�µ�µ�¶�·�¸��®¹�¸°a���;�U¥ ���a�Qªr��ºS�a�.ª��U£���®»�]�a�¼¥ �{�]��½���®�¾¿¨!�]�U¥¿�;�.ÀH¨!��ª�®¯�.�;���{�U¾ ¦Á��¤~�]����ª��.ª��]���n�S¾ ¦~�a�.ª�®b¨�¾�;���{£���¤f�°S���;�U¥ ���a��±{¦F«m°a®d���U¨!ÃSÄr��¥ ��°a®b¨Q³]Å�Æ�Æ�Æ�·]Ç� a¡d�;���~£���¤f¨!��ªÈ«m¡d�;���{£���¤��¸°a���;�U¥ ���a�»¨!®d�ªr�����0¾ ¦¼�;���a�a�.�;�]�.ª»É»¥ �]��Éz�.¾¿¾ ¡O�d�S¾ £L¨!±�¥¿¾¿¥ �A¦F¥ �Á�;�SÊ�±�¥ ��¨!�]��®k¥¿¨�¾.���S�U¥¿Êm¥ Ë.¨!�U¥ �����a®¯��±0¾ �.Ê��zÉÌ¥ �]��;���{£���¤���±ÎÍ`�.�;�U¥ £����¸°a���;�U¥ ���S�bÇLÏ;���]��¥ ����¨!�n��®bÀ{Éz���;���a�b¥¿ªr��®Ð�]�a���¯�¹�;���0�;���a�]���¸��®ÌÑU°�¨�ªr®k¨!�U¥¿��¸°a���;�U¥ ���a�C¨!��ªQ�]�a��d�]®¯°��;�]°a®¯�»�S�n�]�a���;�~��Ò¼��¥ ���{�mÊm¨!�]®b¥¿�;���@�S�Ó�¯°0�O��ÑW°�¨�ª�®b¨!�U¥¿�»�¸°a���;�U¥ ���S�bÇÏ;�m¥ �@�¯�a�UÉ��Ô�]�0¨!�QÑW°�¨�ª�®b¨!�U¥¿�� ¢¡d�;���{£���¤�¨!�0ªÔ«Q¡d�;���{£���¤��¸°a���;�U¥ ���S�Q��¨!�Á±Ó���O�0¨!®b¨��;�]��®b¥ Ë��.ª±{¦¼�0¥¿�;�¼�;�SÊ�±0¥ ��¨!�]��®b¥¿¨�¾Y�a®¯���n��®¯�U¥ ���Õ�S�Y�]�a�.¥ ®��;�{��Ò¼��¥ ���{��Êm¨!�]®k¥¿�;���bÇ9�&�S���;���SÍc°a½S¨��;¦Á®d�.¾¿¨!¡�U¥ ���a�d��¥ ��±n���§ÉH�����7ÑU°�¨�ªr®b¨!�U¥¿� ¢¡d�;���{£���¤f¨!��ª�«Q¡d�;���~£���¤f�¸°a���;�U¥ ���a�Ì¥ �̨�¾ �¯�¼ªS¥ �b�;°a�¯�¯�.ªSÇ

Ö Nbim×�V>G;J>pdجªS¥ �b�;®¯���]�Õ���a�U¥¿ÊQ¥ Ë.¨!�U¥ ����ÀYÊm¨!�]®d�S¥¿ªaÀL±�¨!�¯��Ó�S¾ ¦{�a�.ªr®d����ÀnÑW°�¨�ª�®b¨!�U¥¿�Õ�¸°a���;�U¥ ���

Ù ÚUÛ&ÜrÝ>Þ&ß9àzá¢Ükâ§ÞÎÛ

ãåäaænçLèné�çbê�ëíì�îOænïÓìdê�ëíðLï�ñFòÓóÈô�õöó÷ëíøùènúkûÓïnúkèÈürýþçLï�ÿ��ÿ�é�úkç��Sø§ý�����údê�é�ëcì���çbêré!ë� çLø

ñ��� ������� �� �� �� ó ô ��� � ����� �

� ê�ëíø! Ìú"�#�$&%aïnð� QïÌê('nçUê@ñÈëcøzìkðLï*)�ú+�þëíînçLïÓè�ðLï,� ýÈëcî ëíø.-YðLø!ë ê�ë)�ú�ø!ú"��ëíènúkûÓïnëÂêrú � � ï»ê('nëíø-nç�-Yúké0/� Ìú�ìbðLïnø!ëíènúbé�äaænçLèné�çbê�ëíì�ìkð{ï()nú1� îOænïnì¯ê�ëíðLïnø�úbäSæÓë2-,-Yúkè3 Që ê('54¯ìkð��¹ünëíïnçbê�ð{é!ëíç��ø§êré!ænì¯ê�æné�úkø �#687 'nëíø9ëcønê�ç{ï�êrç���ðLænïrê�ê�ðëcï*)núkø§êrë29{çbê�ëíï,9Ìø ý��:��ú¯ê�é!ëíì;��çbêré!ëíìkúbø� Që ê('¹ø!ð���úìkð��¹ünëíïnçbê�ð{é!ëíç��<-né!ð=-�úbé§ê�ëíúkøëíïfç{ènènë ê�ëíðLï�êrð�-�ðLø�ëÂêrë>)nú¹ø�ú"��ëíènúkûnïÓëÂêrúkïnúbø!ø �? çLïrý5ènë#@�úbé!úkïrê7ì"�íçLø!ø�úkøþð{îA��çbê�é�ëcìbúkøB QëÂê*'åìkð=��ünëíïnçbêrðLé!ëíç���-né!ð=-�úbé§ê�ëíúkø:'nç�)�ú�ü�úbúkïëcï*)núkø§êrë29{çbê�úbè ëíï�ê*'núÁçLé�úkç�ðLî���çbê�é�ë>�¬ê*'núkð{é§ý � ã ê]ýC-Óëcìbç��@ú1��ç���-,�íú�ëíøÌê('ÓúÁì"�íçLø!ø�ðLî

DFE+G�H�E+IKJML=N�OQP*RSITLULVG&WXLVY�Z\[KN1G^]_IKG&E�`Qa&IKG&JQa&G&bcO([ d^egfih(h(jlk^mnG^]_IKN+G&Wpo�HCE+IK[Ke(fih(hlq(k^r;Y=]lG&RsPtG&E+e^fih(hlq

Page 2: 東京工業大学shioura/papers/quadML.pdf! " # $&%(' )+*,' -.)0/.$ 1 $&2 3547698;:&)&= 8@? = 8A)&' ->$CB DFEHG;I>J>KLI>MONQPSRUT>VWV.XYVAZ []\!ZWV>G!^ I>MO_`V>\FPaRb_cNb\aRdN

? $&��çbêré!ëíìkúbø�ê('nçbê�ç�-,-YúkçLéÌëcï3)(çLé�ëcðLæÓøÌçLé�úkçLø�ø�ænì&'�çLø�ú��cúbìdê�é�ëcì�úbï,9Lëíïnúkúbé!ëíï,9�/ùìbðLïrê�é�ð��úkï,9{ëcïnúbúké�ëcï,9vu ��w�x /9ïSæc�Èúbé!ëíìkç��zçLïnç�� ý�ø!ëíø�u � / �=y�x /9çLïnèz�ÈçUê('nú��ÈçUê�ëíìkç��9úkìbðLïnð���ëíìkø:u ��{�x �ãÌïÌÿS�@ÿ�é!úkç=�|��çbêré!ë� ëíøHìkç=�2�íúkè�çLï ? $&��çbêré!ë�¼ëcî �~}g���3�X/g S'núbé!ú��­ëcøzçLïÌÿX��ÿïnðLïnïÓú"9Lçbêrë>)nú���çbê�é�ë>� çLïÓè�}�ëcø»çÔé�úkç���ïaæ,��üYúkéA9Lé!úbçbê�úbé�ê('ÓçLï��F�T���l/�ê('núX��ç���ë2�¹æ,���ð(ènæc�cænø¼ðLî�çLï²úkë#9Lúkï*)(ç��íænú�ðLîA� � � ï�-nçLé ê�ëíìkæ,�íçLé0/»ç ïnðLïnø�ëcï,9{æ,�cç{é ? $��ÈçUê�é!ë�­ëíøÔç��çbê�é�ë>��ø!æÓì&'¹ê('nçUê�úbçLì&'þð�@�$�ènëíç�9Lð{ïnç���ìkð=�:-YðLïnúbïrêCëíø�ïnðLïc-�ðLø�ëÂêrë>)nú�çLïnè¼ëÂêrø�ëíï*)�úké�ø!ú�ëíøç�ïnðLïnïnú�9Lçbêrë>)núX��çbêré!ë� � ã»ïÈÿ��Áÿ ènëcç=9LðLïnç��#� ýi$}ènð���ëíïnçLïrê¹ø§ý����Èú¯ê�é�ëcì ? $&��çbêré!ë� ìkçLïfüYúQì&'ÓçLé!çLì¯ê�úbé!ë#�kúkè�ürýÁê('númîOð��#�cð� Qëíï,9�-né!ð=-�úbé§ê]ý ðLî9ç�ìkð��¹ünëcïÓçbê�ðLé�ëcç=��ïnçbê�æÓé!úkò

�g������� ���M�&�1�����3���8����i��� �M� �g������� ���M�n�����l� � ��� � �

S'núké�úA����� � � � �*�"�*���dÿ�  �,¡ ðbê�úùê('Óçbêçmø§ý����Èú¯ê�é�ëcìp�ÈçUê�é!ë� ëíø�ìkç��#�cúbè¼çmìbð���-nçLé§ê0$��úkïrê�ç��\��çbê�é�ë>��u � x ëíî�� ø!çUê�ëíø!ûnúbøÐê('núX-né!ð=-�úbé§ê]ý�� �¢� � � ��£ úkú¤u>¥ x îOð{ép��çbê*'nú"��çbêrëcìbç��-né!ð=-�úbé§ê�ëíúkøðLî ? $&��çbêré!ëíìkúbø �7 'nú�ìbðLïnìbú"-~ê�ðLCëíé!ëíì&',�cú¯ê�îOð{él��øÌëíø»èÓúkú"-c�Âý ìkðLïÓïnúkì¯ê�úkè: QëÂê*' ? $&��çbêré!ëíìkúbø � � ïnènúkúbè,/çmäSæÓçLèné!çUê�ëíìîOæÓïnìdêrëcðLïz� ��¨ � �© � �ëíø�çS¦Cëíé!ëíì&',�íúdê»îOðLé0���§ð{î�ûnïÓëÂêrúèÓë2��úkïÓø!ëíðLï,��ëcî�çLïnèðLï,� ýfëcî ëíø�ç¹ènëíç�9Lð{ïnç��#�ÂýQ$�èÓð���ëcïnç{ï�êÌø§ý�����údêré!ëíì ? $��ÈçUê�é!ë� ��7 'núA¦Cëíé!ëíì&',�íúdêÌîOðLél� ëíøç¼îOæÓïnènç���úkïrêrç��Îêrð(ð=�&ëcï�-né!ð{ünçLünë#�cë ê]ýÁê('ÓúkðLé ý�� ? çLé0%{ð�)ª-né!ðSìkúbø!ø0/9ëíïz-ÓçLé§êrëcìbæ,�cç{él�çLïnè-�ðUê�úkïrêrëcç��0ê*'núkð{é§ý5u«�/ � � x � � êÈëíøS%aïnð� QïFê('nçbêÈ符Cëíé!ëíì&',�íúdê¼îOðLél� ñ��K ��8�­� �"¨ � �© � ìkçLïfüYúQì&'ÓçLé!çLì¯ê�úbé!ë#�kúkè�ürýÁê('númîOð��#�cð� Qëíï,9�ìkð��¹ünëíïnçbê�ð{é!ëíç���-né!ð�-Yúké ê]ý�ò

ñ��� �� � ñ��0�¯®s°: ��\± Ù � �K�M ²� ó ô ���

S'núké�ú�®þçLïnè Ù ènúbïnðbêrú�ê*'nú§)�úbìdê�ð{é!ø< QëÂê*'¼ç��#��ìkð=�:-YðLïnúbïrê�ø�ü�úbëcï,9múbäSæÓç��Lê�ð³�kúbé!ðQçLïnèðLïnú�/Yé�úkø0-�úbìdê�ë)�ú��Âý�/0çLïÓèÔîOðLé�çLïrý� \�0´¬��ó ô ê('nú�)�úbìdêrðLé!ø\ ³±A´µ�1 ³°A´¬� ó ô ç{é!ú¶9Lë>)núkïürý

�� ¤±:´�� � ����ëíïM�" � �0´ �  �� �K ¤°:´C� � ����ç��µ�" � �0´ �   ���·� � � � �*�"�*���dÿ§���

£ ænì&' çfìbð���üÓëcïnçUê�ðLé�ëcç���-Óé!ð�-Yúké ê]ý+ðLîn¦Cëíé!ëíì&',�íúdê¼îOðLé0�ÈømìbçLï üYú�ø!úbúkï çLømç�é�ú"¸núbìdê�ëíðLïðLî(ê*'núÌìbð���ünëíïnçbêrðLé!ëíç��Yø§êré!ænì¯ê�æné�úÌðLî&èÓëcç�9{ðLïnç��#�ÂýQ$}ènð���ëcïÓçLïrêCø§ý�����údêré!ëíì ? $&��çbêré!ëíìkúbø �� ï¤��ðLé!úp-,'rý�ø!ëíìkç��(êrúké0�Èø0/Sê*'núA¦Cëíé!ëíì&',�íúdêmîOðLé0� ëcø�úkäaænë)Óç=�cúbï�ê�ê�ð¬� ðLéÐé�ú"-né�úkø�úkïrê�úbè�çLø0�ú"�íúkì¯ê�é!ëíìkç=�nïnúdêU ÌðLé0%Sø�ð{é�ê�ð�é�çLïnènð=�¹ Ìç��#%aø �M7 'nú�-Óé!úkø�úkïrêø§êrænè~ýX Që2�#�2/|'nð�-YúkîOæ,�#� ý�/Óø0'núkèç�ïnú1 º�íë#9�'rê�ð{ï�ê*'núkø�ú¹îOæÓïnènç���úkïrêrç���ìkðLïnìbú"-~êrø �� ï ê*'nú�ç{é!úkç ðLîÌìbð���üÓëcïnçUê�ðLé�ëcç��Õð�-.ê�ë#�Èë#�kçUê�ëíðLï,/ðLï�ê*'nú7ðUê('núbé�'nç{ïnè,/¤4¯ìkð=��ünëíïnçbêrð�$é!ëíç���ìbðLï*)�ú1��ë ê]ý�/ 6 ë � ú � /CìbðLï*)�ú+�0ë ê]ý úkäaænë#-,-Yúkè» QëÂê*'5ïnëíìkú�ìbð���üÓëcïnçUê�ðLé�ëcç��B-Óé!ð�-Yúké ê�ëíúkø'nçLøÐç��cø�ð�üYúkúbïþëcï*)núkø§êrë29{çbê�úbè�� ø!úbú"/Yú � 9 � /.u w�¼�y / � «�/ � w / � « x � �M7 'nú»é!ú��cçbêrëcð{ïnøl'në#-ÁüYúdêU Ìúkúkïø!ænüc�ÈðSènæ,�íçLé�îOænïnì¯ê�ëíðLïnø�çLïÓèÈìbðLï*)�ú+�fîOænïnìdêrëcð{ïnøµ �çLø���çLèÓú@ì"�íúkçLé&ê('Óé!ðLæ,9='Ìê('nú. ÌðLél%aøürý¹½Îé!çLïc%¾u¿ x /;½ÎætÀdëíøl'në#9Lúvu y�x /ÐçLïnè»Á�ð�)�ÂçLøl�ªu � « x � ? ë#�2�íúkéÃu � w�x çLïn軽Îç�)(çbê�ë ¼ 7 çLé!ènú��2�íçu w=x ëcï*)núkø§êrë29{çbê�úbè7ì"�íçLø�ø!úkøÕðLîB4¯ènëíø!ìbé!ú¯ê�úmìkðLï*)nú1� 6 îOænïÓìdê�ëíðLïnø@èÓúkûnïnúbè7ð�)�úbéùê('núCëíïrê�ú"9{úké

Page 3: 東京工業大学shioura/papers/quadML.pdf! " # $&%(' )+*,' -.)0/.$ 1 $&2 3547698;:&)&= 8@? = 8A)&' ->$CB DFEHG;I>J>KLI>MONQPSRUT>VWV.XYVAZ []\!ZWV>G!^ I>MO_`V>\FPaRb_cNb\aRdN

�cçUê!ê�ëíìkúÐø!ænì&'Ìê*'nçbê��cðSìkç��að�-.ê�ë#�Èç=�cë ê]ýþë#��-,�íëcúbø§9��íðLünç��að�-~êrë2��ç��íë ê]ý � � ï�-nçLé§êrëcìbæ,�íçLél/i-né!ð{üt$�cú���ø¶ Që ê(' äaænç{èné!çbêrëcìÈðLü|Àdúbìdêrë>)núþîOænïnì¯ê�ëíðLïnø�ç{é!ú�ðLîgê�úbï ènëíø!ìbænø!ø�úkè ëíïfê*'nú��íë ê�úké�çbê�æÓé!úu { / ��� ¼ � ¥ x � ? çLïrýÁðLî.ê('nðLø�ú�äaænçLèné�çbê�ëíì�-né�ðLü,�íú"��ø�'nç�)�ú�ïnëcìbú@ìkð��¹ünëíïnçbê�ð{é!ëíç��(ø ê�é�ænìdêræné!úçLïnèfìkçLïfüYúQø�ð��)�úkè7ü�ý ú�Ä�ìkëíúkïrê�ìbð���üÓëcïnçUê�ðLé�ëcç���ç��#9LðLé�ëÂê*',��ø � � ê¹ëíø»ç��íø!ð:'nð�-Yúkè�ê('Óçbêê('nú�-né!úbø!úkïrê¼ø§êrænè~ý�-né!ð�)�ëcèÓúkømçþìkð=�:��ðLï�îOé�ç���ú1 ÌðLél%�îOðLéÌø�ænì&' ú�Ä�ìkëíúkïrê(� ý ø!ð=�>)(çLü,�íúäaænçLèné�çbê�ëíìmìkð��¹ünëcïÓçbê�ðLé�ëcç=��ð�-~ê�ë#��ë2�bçbê�ëíðLïÃ-né!ð{ü,�cú���ø �7 'nú�ìkð{ïnìkú�-~ê�øÁðLî³Á,$�ìbðLï*)�ú+�0ë ê]ý çLïÓè ? $�ìbðLï*)�ú1��ë ê]ý,çLé!ú7ëcïrê�é�ð(èÓænìkúbè­îOð{éþîOænïnì¯ê�ëíðLïnøènúkûÓïnúkè+ð�)�úké�ê*'núÁëcïrêrú"9Lúbé:�íçbê�ê�ëíìkúÁürý ? æÓé!ðbêrç�u � ¿ ¼ ��Å x /\ Që ê(' ç3)�ëcú+ ê�ð�ëíènúkïrêrëcîgýQ$ëcïc9�ïnëcìbúCìkð��¹ünëíïnçbê�ð{é!ëíç��0ø ê�é!æÓìdê�æÓé!úCëíïÁìkð��¹ünëcïÓçbê�ðLé�ëcç=�&ð�-~êrë2��ë#�kçbêrëcðLïÆ-Óé!ðLü,�íú"��ø. Që ê('�T9Lúbïnúké�ç��#��ïnðLï,�íëcïÓúkçLé�ðLü|Àdúbìdêrë>)núÐîOænïÓìdê�ëíðLïnø � Á�çbê�úbél/kê('Óú�ìkðLïnìbú"-~êrøzð{îiÁ.ÇÈ$�ìbðLï*)�ú1��ë ê]ý¼çLïnè? ÇÈ$�ìkð{ï()nú1��ë ê]ý�çLé!úÌëcïrê�é�ð(èÓænìkúbèfürý�½Yæ^Àdëcø0'në29{ú ¼ ? æÓé!ðbêrçÃu Å x çLïnèÁürý ? æné!ðbêrç ¼ £ 'ÓëcðLæÓé!çu � � x /�é!úbøl-Yúkì¯ê�ë)�ú"� ý�/ÕçLø�)(çLé!ëíçLïrê�ø�ð{î�ÁM$}ìkðLï*)nú1��ëÂê]ý çLïnè ? $}ìkðLï*)nú1��ëÂê]ý ��7 'núþìkð{ïnìkú�-~ê�øðLî§Á,$�ìbðLï*)�ú+�0ë ê]ý ç{ïnè ? $}ìkðLï*)�ú+��ëÂê]ý¬çLé!ú¹ú1�aê�úbïnènúkèÔêrð¤-Yð��Âý�'núbèné!ç=�zìbðLï*)�ú1�¬îOænïnì¯ê�ëíðLïnøènúkûÓïnúkèåð�)núkéCê('núFé!úbç��Õøl-nç{ìkúfü�ý ? æné!ðbêrç ¼ £ 'ÓëcðLæÓé!ç�u � � x �.É çLé�ëcç{ï�êrø�ðLîA-Yð�� ýC'Óúkèné�ç��Á,$�ìkð{ï()nú1�fçLïÓè ? $}ìkðLï*)nú1��îOænïnì¯ê�ëíðLïnøl/Îìbç��2�íúkè�-�ð=�Âý�'núbèné!ç��MÁ Ç $�ìbðLï*)�ú1�fç{ïnè ? Ç $}ìkðLï*)�ú+�îOænïnì¯ê�ëíðLïnøl/�çLé�úCç��íø!ðÈëcïrê�é�ð(èÓænìkúbè7ëíï�u � � x �ãA� ê('nð{æ,9�'7ê('ÓúÁìkðLïnìbú"-~êrø�ðLî�Á,$&Ê�Á Ç $�ìbðLï*)�ú1��ë ê]ý©çLïnè ? $&Ê ? Ç $�ìbðLï*)�ú+�0ë ê]ý©çLé�úþènúbûnïnúkèîOðLés-Yð��Âý�'núbèné!ç=�@ìkðLï*)�ú+�­îOænïnì¯ê�ëíðLïnøl/. ÌúfìkçLï ïnçbêræné!ç=�2� ý©ú1�aêrúkïnè�ê('núbø!úFìkðLïÓìkú"-.ê�øCê�ðäaænçLèné�çbê�ëíì�îOænïÓìdê�ëíðLïnø �|7 'Óëcøzú1�aê�úbïnø!ëíðLïs-né�ð&)�ëíènúkøzçÌïnëíìkúÐîOé!ç���ú+ �ðLé0%mîOðLé, �ú��2�$�ø�ð��>)(çLüc�cúäaænçLèné�çbê�ëíì�ìkð��¹ünëcïÓçbê�ðLé�ëcç=��ð=-~ê�ë#��ë2�bçbê�ëíðLïv-né!ðLüc�cú��Èø ��7 'nú��Èç{ëcï çLë#� ðLî�ê('nëíøX-Óç�-�úbéëcø@ê�ðfëíï()núkø ê�ë#9Lçbê�úmê('núÈìkð=��ünëíïnçbêrðLé!ëíç���-né!ð=-�úbé§ê�ëíúkøQðLîÐäSæÓçLèné!çUê�ëíì�Á,$&Ê=Á§ÇË$}ìkðLï*)�ú+�²çLïnè? $&Ê ? ÇÌ$}ìkðLï*)nú1� îOænïnìdêrëcð{ïnø�çLïÓè�ê('nú¼ø§êré!ænì¯ê�æné�úþðLîzê*'núkëíé�ìbð(ú�ÄÈìbëcúbïrê¬��çbê�é�ëcìbúkø �n7 'núé!úbø!æ,� ê�øÐëcïmê('nëíøn-Óç�-�úbéµ Që2�#��üYú�'nú"�#-nîOæ,�YëíïÔëíènúkïrê�ëíîgý�ëcïc9¶ Ìú"�#�>$}ø!ð��)(çLü,�íú�äaænçLèné�çbê�ëíì»ìbð��8$ünëíïnçbê�ð{é!ëíç���ð�-~êrë2��ë#�kçbêrëcð{ïÍ-Óé!ðLü,�íú"��ø � � ïnènúkúbè,/ÕëÂêfìbçLï ü�úÁø0'nð� Qï²ürý©æÓø!ëíï,9�ðLæné�é!ú+$ø!æ,� ê�ømê('nçUê�ïnð{ïnø!ú�-nçLé!ç{ü,�cú�äaænçLèné�çbê�ëíì�ð{ü|Àdúkì¯ê�ë)�ú�îOænïÓìdê�ëíðLïnømê�é�úkçbêrúkè ëíï~u ��� / � {�x çLé�úäaænçLèné�çbê�ëíì ? $�ìbðLï*)�ú1��îOænïÓìdê�ëíðLïnø0/� S'nëcì&'¼ú1��-,�íçLëíïnø\ Ìú"�#�>$}ø!ð��)(çLünë#�cë ê]ý�ðLî¢ê('núÕäaænçLèné�çbê�ëíììkð��¹ünëíïnçbê�ð{é!ëíç��Ðð=-~ê�ë#��ë2�bçbê�ëíðLï�-Óé!ðLü,�íú"��ø¹ëcïÎu ��� / � {�x � ½ÎðLémìkð��¹ünëíïnçbê�ð{é!ëíç��Ðð=-~ê�ë#��ë2�bç�$ê�ëíðLï�-né�ðLü,�íú"��ø� Që ê('�äaænç{èné!çbêrëcì;ÁM$�Ê ? $}ìkðLï*)�ú+�þð{ü|Àdúkì¯ê�ë)�ú�îOænïÓìdê�ëíðLïnø0/ÓðLæÓéHé!úbø!æ,� ê�ø! Që2�#�ü�úmænø�úkîOæ,��ëíïfènú1)nú"�íð�-nëíï,9þú"Ä�ìbëcúbï�ê�ìkð=��ünëíïnçbêrðLé!ëíç���ç��#9LðLé�ëÂê*',��ø �Ï ú�ø0'nð� ê*'nçbê�çÔäSæÓçLèné!çUê�ëíì�îOænïnìdêrëcð{ï ñª9Lë>)núkï ürý5� �¢�Ð� �»ëcøBÁ Ç $�ìbðLï*)�ú+� ëcî�çLïÓè�ðLï,� ýëcîÕë ê�ø�ìbð(ú�ÄÈìbëcúbïrêz��çbêré!ë� ëcø�ç�ènëíç�9Lð{ïnç��#�ÂýQ$�èÓð���ëcïnç{ï�êfø ý��:��ú¯ê�é!ëíì ? $&��çbêré!ë� � ãø!ë#��ë2�íçLéÌì&'ÓçLé!çLì¯ê�úbé!ë#�kçbêrëcðLï7ðLîHçÈäaænçLèné�çbê�ëíì�Á,$�ìbðLï*)�ú+�¬îOænïÓìdê�ëíðLï�ëcø¶9Lë)�úkï7ëcï�ê�úké0��øÌðLîê('núÈø!ë#9Lï�-Óçbê!êrúké!ï ðLîzê*'nú¼ìbð(ú�Ä�ìkëíúkïrê¬��çbê�é�ë>� � ãÌø¹îOðLé ? $&Ê ? ÇÌ$}ìkðLï*)nú1��ëÂê]ý�/\ Ìúþøl'Óð& ê('nçUê�ç»äaænçLèné�çbê�ëíìÐîOæÓïnìdêrëcðLï�ñ�9Lë)�úbï�ürý�� ����� �, Që ê('�ç»ïnðLïnø�ëcïc9Læ,�íçLézìbð(ú�Ä�ìkëíúkïrê���çbêré!ë� ëíø ? Ç $�ìkð{ï()nú1��ëcî�çLïÓèÁðLï,� ý�ëíî ø!çUê�ëíø!ûnúbøHê('nú�îOð=�2�íð� Qëcï,9�ìbð���üÓëcïnçUê�ðLé�ëcç���-né!ð=-�úbé§ê]ý�ò

� �^��Ñ �Èëíï¶� � �"��ëíï�lÒ��� � �g�   ���M ²��ó ô ���M�;� ø�æ,-,-!Ó§�K ��l��� � ��� { �

S'núké�ú�ø�æ,-,- Ó �K ����Ô�"�¤�º� ÕC ��Ñ��  �çLïnè �g� ���¤�Ö�Ã��ènúkïÓðbê�úbømê*'nús�©$;ê*' ìkð��$æ,��ï�)�úkì¯ê�ðLé�ðLî � ? ðLé!úbð�)�úké0/Hê('nëíø�ìkðLïÓènëÂêrëcð{ï�� ��� { �»ê�æÓé!ïnø�ðLæ~ê�ê�ð�ü�úÁúbäaænë>)(ç��íúkïrêê�ðÌê*'núCëcï*)núké!ø�úmðLî��ÈçUê�é!ë� ü�úbëcï,9�ç�èÓëcç�9{ðLïnç��#�ÂýQ$}ènð���ëcïÓçLïrêQø§ý����Èú¯ê�é�ëcì ? $��ÈçUê�é!ë� �

{

Page 4: 東京工業大学shioura/papers/quadML.pdf! " # $&%(' )+*,' -.)0/.$ 1 $&2 3547698;:&)&= 8@? = 8A)&' ->$CB DFEHG;I>J>KLI>MONQPSRUT>VWV.XYVAZ []\!ZWV>G!^ I>MO_`V>\FPaRb_cNb\aRdN

7 'nëíø»é�ú1)�úbç��íøÌçÈïnëcìbú¹ìbðLïtÀdæ,9{çLìdý�é�ú"�íçbê�ëíðLïnø0'në#-�ü�ú¯êU �úbúkï�äaænç{èné!çbêrëcì³Á Ç $�ìkð{ï()nú1� îOænïnì+$ê�ëíðLïnø»çLïnè ? Ç $�ìbðLï*)�ú+� îOænïnì¯ê�ëíðLïnø�ú+��-né!úbø!ø!úbè�ëcï¼êrúké0�ÈøÌðLî0ê('nú¹ìkðSú"Ä�ìkëíúkïrê���çbêré!ëíìkúbøl/ S'núké�ú�ê('nú�ìbðLïtÀdæ,9Lç{ìdý»��úbçLïnø�ê('núsÁ�ú�9LúkïnèÓé!ú ¼ ½Yúbïnì&'nú���ìbðLïtÀdæ,9{çLìdý �§7 'nú�ìkðLï^Àdæ,9LçLì¯ýé!ú��cçbêrëcð{ïnøl'në#-7ú+�aê�úkïÓènø�êrð�ïnðLïnäaænçLèÓé!çbêrëcìQìkðLï*)nú1� îOænïnì¯ê�ëíðLïnøXu �=��x �Ï ú�ç��íø!ðFìbðLïnø!ëíènúbéXÁ,$&Ê=Á Ç $}ìkðLï*)�ú+�+çLïnè ? $�Ê ? Ç $�ìkð{ï()nú1�+îOænïÓìdê�ëíðLïnømènúbûnïnúbè ð�)�úbéB× ô�¿ê*'nú¹ëíïrê�ú�9Lúkép�cçbê�ê�ëíìkú��l/9çLïnè7ìbð���-nçLé�úÕê*'nú"� ê�ðCê('ÓðLø!ú¹ð&)núkéÕó ô ��7 'nëíøÌëíø�ê�ðÔëíïnènëíìkçUê�úç�ø!æÓü~ê(�íúÔènë#@Yúké!úbïnìkúÁüYúdêU Ìúkúbï�ê('nú¼ènëcø�ìké�údê�úÔìkçLø�úþçLïnè�ê*'núÔìbðLïrê�ëíïaænðLænø�ìbçLø!ú�/�úbøl-Yú1$ìkëíç��#�ÂýÆ Që ê(' ? $�ìbðLï*)�ú1��ë ê]ý � � ê�ëíøÕøl'nð� Qï¼ê*'nçbêÕê('núQì"�íçLø�ø!úkø»ðLîHìbð(ú�Ä�ìkëíúkïrês��çbêré!ëíìkúkøðLîÁ,$&Ê�Á.ÇË$�ìbðLï*)�ú1� îOæÓïnìdêrëcðLïÓøð�)núké�×�ôþìbðLëcïÓìkëíènú� QëÂê*'�ê*'nðLø!úmîOðLé�óÈôi/i S'núké�úkçLø�ê('núCìbð(úbîÌ$ûnìkëíúkïrê³��çbêré!ëíìkúbø�ðLî&äaænç{èné!çbêrëcì ? $&Ê ? ÇÌ$}ìkðLï*)nú1�7îOænïnìdêrëcð{ïnø�ð�)�úbén×�ô�ìkð{ïnø§êrëÂêræ~ê�úp�Èð{é!úé!úbø§ê�é�ëcì¯ê�ë)�ú¹ì"�íçLø!ø�úkø�ê('nçLï�ê('ÓðLø!úmîOðLé�óÈô �7 'nú ðLé09LçLïnë#�kçbêrëcð{ï,ð{îÌê('nëíø²-nç�-Yúké�ëíø�çLø�îOð��#�cð� Qø � ¦CúkûnïÓëÂêrëcðLïÓø�çLïnè ú1��ç���-,�íúkø�ðLîäaænçLèné�çbê�ëíì3Á,$&Ê=Á§ÇË$}ìkðLï*)�ú+�åç{ïnè ? $�Ê ? ÇË$�ìbðLï*)�ú1� îOænïnì¯ê�ëíðLïnø�ç{é!ú:9Lë>)núkï ëíï £ úbìdê�ëíðLï � �£ ê�é�ænìdêræné!úbøCðLî�äaænçLèné�çbê�ëíì�Á,$&Ê=Á§ÇË$}ìkðLï*)�ú+� çLïÓè ? $&Ê ? ÇÌ$}ìkðLï*)nú1� îOæÓïnìdêrëcðLïÓøCçLé!ú¹ëcï*)�úbøT$ê�ë#9Lçbêrúkè ëcï £ úkì¯ê�ëíðLï { /C S'Óë2�íúmê*'nú:-né!ðSðLîOømçLé!ú�9Lë)�úbï ëíï £ úbìdêrëcðLï w ��7 'núÈìkðLï^Àdæ,9LçLì¯ýé!ú��cçbêrëcð{ïnøl'në#-þüYúdêU ÌúkúbïþäaænçLèné�çbê�ëíìAÁ,$&Ê=Á§Ç>$}ìkðLï*)nú1�7çLïnè ? $&Ê ? ÇÌ$}ìkðLï*)�ú+��îOænïnìdêrëcð{ïnø�çLé�úènëíø!ìkæÓø!ø!úbè²ëíï £ úbìdê�ëíðLïØ¥ �·Ù 'nçLé�çLìdêrúké!ë#�kçUê�ëíðLïnø�ðLîÕäaænçLèné�çbê�ëíì¤Á,$&Ê=Á§ÇË$}ìkðLï*)�ú+� çLïÓè ? $Ê ? ÇÈ$�ìbðLï*)�ú1� îOæÓïnìdêrëcðLïÓø»ð�)�úbé�×�ôþçLé�úS-Óé!ð�)�ëcènúbè7ëíï £ úkìdêrëcð{ï�« �

Ú Û¬ÜQÝzÛ9â Ürâ ÞÎÛFÞ:ßnÛ9ß5àAáµß,â�ã\äåÜQÞÔÞ�æ�çþàFßÓßzÝgßnÜrâ á�è·é1ê!ëìédá¢ÞÎÛµí�Üiáïî�àzÛ9á¢Ürâ ÞÎÛFÞ

Ï úÕènúbïnðbêrú»ürýþó ê('Óú»ø�údê»ðLîYé!úkç=�cø0/Yç{ïnè�ü�ýÆ×�ê*'núÕø!údêÌðLîYëcïrêrú"9Lúbé!ø ��7 'né�ðLæ,9�'ÓðLæ~ê�ê('nëíø-nç�-Yúké0/� �ú�çLø�ø!æ,��ú&ê('Óçbê�ÿFëcø�ç�-YðLø!ë ê�ë)�ú�ëíïrê�ú"9{úkél/¢ç{ïnèmènúkïnðUê�ú����~� � � � �*�*�*�¢��ÿ�  � ½ÎðLéçLïrý ûnïnë ê�ú�ø�údê�ð�/�ë ê�ø�ìbçLé!ènëíïnç��íë ê]ý ëíøÌèÓúkïnðbêrúkè�ürýÎÕËðpÕ � ã îOç���ë2� ý���� � �*�¶ñg�*�*�*���*�Aò� ðLî�ø!ænünø�údêrø�ðLîn� ëcøQìkç��#�íúkè ç�ó&ôCõTöC÷"øtù�ú1ùKú1û"ü ð{î;� ëcîn� �Cý � � �ÿþ�îOðLéCçLïrý èÓëcø ê�ëíïnìdê�&�0� �~� � � � �*�"�*��� �  �/�çLïnè ç�öC÷"øtù�ú1ùKú1û"ü ëíî�ë êÔëíø�çfø!æÓü,-nçLé ê�ë ê�ëíðLï¬çLïnè ò�¯�M� � � ��� �7 'nú�ì&'nç{é!çLì¯ê�úké�ëcø ê�ëíì;)�úbìdê�ð{é�ðLî&ç�ø�ænünø�údêSð��~� ëcø�ènúkïnðUê�úkèÁürý����v�©��� � � �   ô �l/Yë � ú � /�����M� � � � îOð{é¶��� ð çLïnèÎ������ � � � îOðLé¶��� ��Xð � Ï úÔènúbïnðbêrú�� � � ��� ��� îOðLé�p�¹��/Hëíï -nçLé ê�ëíìkæ,�íçLé � Ï ú�ø!ð���ú¯ê�ë#�ÈúbøCènúkïÓðbê�ú����S� ® � ½ÎðLé� Ø�+óÈôFçLïnè²ð�� �Ã/ �úQènúbûnïnúp n�Tð��n� ��� � � /�çLïÓè7ènúbïnðbê�úQürý¬ nuËð x � ó � ê*'nú¹é�úkø ê�é!ëíìdêrëcð{ï7ðLî! 7ê�ð�ð �7 'nú�ø!ú¯êÈðLî&ÿÍ�7ÿ é�úkç��ùø ý��:��ú¯ê�é!ëíì���çbê�é�ëcìbúkøCëíøCènúkïnðUê�úkè�ürý�� ô � ½ÎðLé ��� ô çLïnèð�� ��/Yê('nús-né�ëcïÓìkë#-nç���ø!æÓü,��çbê�é�ë>�+ðLî ëíïnènænìbúkè ürý�ê('nú�ëíïnènú+� ø!ú¯ê¤ð©ëíøQèÓúkïnðbêrúkèürý u>ð x ��� ë>)núkï�çÈø�údê¹ðLîM)�úbìdê�ð{é!øn �� � � �0 �� ñ � �*�*�*���0 �� ò � � ó�ôQ/c ÌúQènúkûnïÓú

øl-nç{ï��" � ��� Õ¢�·� � � � �*�*�"��� �  ³�~�ò� �M�"! �

� ��� Õ! � � ó ����� � � � �*�*�*�¢� � �l ��

¥

Page 5: 東京工業大学shioura/papers/quadML.pdf! " # $&%(' )+*,' -.)0/.$ 1 $&2 3547698;:&)&= 8@? = 8A)&' ->$CB DFEHG;I>J>KLI>MONQPSRUT>VWV.XYVAZ []\!ZWV>G!^ I>MO_`V>\FPaRb_cNb\aRdN

½ÎðLéÌçÁø ýC����údêré!ëíì��ÈçUê�é!ë��� �#� ô çLïnè�çÆ�íëcïnúbçLé�ø�ænünøl-ÓçLìkú%$&� ó ô /! Ìú�ènúbûnïnú�çäaænçLèné�çbê�ëíìmîOænïnìdêrëcð{ï%'ÔòÓó ô õ ó)(z�+*-,¹ �ð�)�úbé.$ ürý

'.�0/M��� �� / � �./��0/3��$����*1, �0/ ¨��$���� � � ��� �

Ï úCìbç��#�&ø!ænì&'�ç�äaænçLèné�çbê�ëíìmîOænïnìdêrëcð{ï325476&û"ü�8:9<;mëíîzë êQø!çbêrëcø�ûnúkøùê*'nú³-né!ð�-Yúké ê�ëíúkøS�åÁ\½ � �çLïnè��TÁ�½ � ��ò= è·îQÙ+> '.�0/M�?*#'.��@g� � '.�0/S±�@g�A*#'.�0/S°B@^� �K��/��C@8� èÓð��#'!�l/= è·î�Ú�> DFE � ó ø!æÓì&'Èê('ÓçbêG'.�0/H*�I Ù ���J'.�0/M�A*KI E ����/3� ènð��L'C�MIÆ��ó¬�l/

S'núké�ú�ènð��L'�� �N/z�²óÈô²ÕO'.�0/M�QPR*1,¹  � ã äaænçLèné�çbê�ëíì�îOænïÓìdê�ëíðLïS'�ò0ó�ôÁõ óT(�+*1,¹ �9Lë)�úkïFürý»� � ��� ��ëíø�ìbç��2�íúkè�2.Ç�476&û"ü�8:9<;�ëíîÓê('nú�îOæÓïnìdêrëcðLï 'Ôò(ó U õöóV(¤�+*1,¹ �/ S'núké�ú ���~� �  Q(z��/�ènúbûnïnúkè�ürý

'F�0/W�g�X/M���K'.�0/S��/W� Ù � �l�Y/W�(�Z/M�·� ó U �

ëcø¶Á,$�ìbðLï*)�ú1� � Ï úQìkç��#��ç��íëíïnúkçLéø!æÓünøl-nç{ìkú[$\� ó ô 25476&û"ü�8:9<;Æ� é!úkø0- � /�2 Ç 476&û"ü�8:9<;(�Õëcîê('númëíïnènëíìkçbêrðLéÕîOænïnì¯ê�ëíðLï�]Z^ òÓó ô õ � � �N*1,¹ �èÓúkûnïnúbè7ürý

]<^s�Y/M��� � �Y/��_$����*1, �Y/ ¨�_$��

ëcø�Á,$�ìbðLï*)�ú+���§é!úbøl- � /�Á.ÇÌ$}ìkðLï*)�ú+��� �` Ý>Þ�ã�Þ�Þrâ Ürâ ÞÎÛ¹Úba Ù = á�æcaed�ÚzÙ�f�gihea�j�a�Ú�jlkm>�n óo9(ù�$p�5óÈô¤ú¯ó�÷"ü�25476&û"ü�8:9<;Sq�ør9ló�öbsut2.Ç�476&û"ü�8:9<;<vBw ú¯üx9&÷"øBó&ôCõló�öC÷W6y9púuz�÷"üx{Æû"üxw |:úuz.$­� ø0-nçLï��W� Ux} Õ+~:� � � � �*�*�"��� �  -z"û"øó^ûN�39�öC÷"øtù�ú1ùKú1û"ü�q�ør9ló�öbsut§ó&ôCõTöC÷"ø=ùKú1ùKú1û"üFv������:ÕF~�� � � � �*�*�*��� �   ûXzp��s

½ÎðLé�çÁø§ý�����údêré!ëíì:��çbêré!ë� ��� ô çLïnè�çÆ�íëíïnúkçLéCø�ænünø0-nçLìkú%��� ó ô /� �ú�ènúbûnïnú�çäaænçLèné�çbê�ëíìmîOænïnìdêrëcð{ï7ñFòÓóÈô�õöóR(z�+*1,¹ Èð�)núké.��ürý

ñ��� ���� �� � 5�K ���z�l�*1, �K ¨���z�l� � � � � �

«

Page 6: 東京工業大学shioura/papers/quadML.pdf! " # $&%(' )+*,' -.)0/.$ 1 $&2 3547698;:&)&= 8@? = 8A)&' ->$CB DFEHG;I>J>KLI>MONQPSRUT>VWV.XYVAZ []\!ZWV>G!^ I>MO_`V>\FPaRb_cNb\aRdN

Ï úFìbç��2��ø!ænì&'²ç äaænç{èné!çbêrëcìÁîOæÓïnìdêrëcðLï��3476&û"ü�8:9<;fëíîëÂêfø�çbê�ëíø!ûnúbømê*'nú¬-né!ð=-�úbé§ê]ý � ? $��� Ù �!ò

= ëìé1à��%�%> �M \�1´¬� ènð�� ñC/c�M�;� ø!æc-,- Ó �� 3��´��l/ D �s� ø!æ,-c-l�§�� ¤�ª´C�0/ D!� Ñ�� ò

ñ��K ��A*åñ��K´C� � ñ��� ¤�!�� � ��� � �l�A* ñ���´i*

!�� � ��� � �0� ���

!�¹� � � ! � x �l�

S'núké�úÁø!æ,-c- Ó ���=��� �"��� � Õ�� �AÑ �  �ç{ïnè¬ø!æc-,- � ���t�s�­�"�s� � Õ5� � P �  �îOðLé�¬�©ó ô � ã÷äSæÓçLèné!çUê�ëíìÈîOæÓïnìdêrëcðLï ñ¬òzó ô õ ó�(��+*1,¹ Æ9Lë>)núkï ü�ý�� � � � �CëcøQìkç=�2�íúkè? Ç�476&û"ü�8:9<;Qëíî�ê('núCîOænïÓìdê�ëíðLï ñÁòÓó U õ ó)(Ã�+*1,¹ �/i S'núbé!ú ����� �  G(z�Ã/&ènúbûnïnúkèürý

ñ��� ��g�1 ���� ñ��� ����� ��¶�~�� n�©�Ã�l���*1, �§ðUê('núbéT Qëíø!ú*� �0�� ��g�0 ��·� ó U �

ëcø ? $�ìbðLï*)�ú+� � ãA�íø!ð�/� �ú»ìkç��#�Yç��íëcïnúbçLé�ø�ænünø0-nçLìkúM�3476&û"ü�8:9<;s� é!úbøl- � /?��Ç�476&û"ü�8:9<;(��ëíî&ë ê�øëcïÓènëcìbçbê�ð{éîOæÓïnìdêrëcðLïfëíø ? $�ìkð{ï()nú1�¾�§é�úkø0- � / ? ÇÌ$}ìkðLï*)�ú+��� �` Ý>Þ�ã�Þ�Þrâ Ürâ ÞÎÛ¹Úba�Ú = á�æcaed�ÚzÙ�f�gihea�j�a�j�k>�n óo9(ùb���,ó ô ú¯ó3÷"üL�3476&û"ü�8:9<;�q�ør9ló�öbsut� Ç 476&û"ü�8:9<;<vLw ú¯üx9&÷"øsó&ôCõló�öC÷W6y9Súuz:÷"üx{�û"üxw |¬úuz�ù0�l9lør9S9<;(ú¯ó^ùKó¬÷³öC÷"øtùKú1ù�ú1û"ü�q�øN9ló�öbsut;ó&ôµõ<4öC÷"øtù�ú1ùKú1û"üFv ���.�ÍÕb~»� � � � �*�*�*�¢� �  ïûXz�� ó&ô�6<��ùY�!÷�ù�� � �" �� óÈôÎÕ! n�T���t�s�� ��~s� � � � �*�*�"��� � �l �sà8áµß,âªãFäåÜ Ú�a�j�� ænçLèné�çbê�ëíì ? $�Ê�Á,$�ìkð{ï()nú1��îOæÓïnìdêrëcðLïÓø9ç{é!ëíø!ú�îOé!ð=� ú"�íúkì¯ê�é�ëcìbç��¢ïnúdêU ÌðLé0%Sø QëÂê*'��íëcïnúbçLéÌé�úkø�ëcø ê�ðLé�ø �\Ù ðLïnø!ëíènúbé�çLï7ú��cúbìdêré!ëíìkç��zïnúdêU ÌðLél%� Që ê('�ç¼üné!ç{ïnì&'�ø!ú¯ê çLïnèçþïnðSènú�ø�údê%��/zçLïnè�ø�æ,-,-YðLø!úÌê*'nçbê»ê�úké0��ëcïnç=�ùø!ú¯êM���T�X/zçþìkæÓé!é!úbïrêÈø!ðLæné�ìkúA)núkìdêrðLé ï�©ó%�µ/ùç{ïnè ç¬-Yðbê�úbïrê�ëíç��C)�úbìdê�ð{éG/v� ó%� çLé!ús9Lë)�úbï � Ï ú�ènúbïnðbêrúCê*'nú�é!úbø!ëíø§ê�ç{ïnìkúðLî9üné!çLïÓì&' � � ürýL���g/Óê('ÓúS-Yðbêrúkïrê�ëíç���çbêQïnðSènú��Æ�_� ürý�/��(/Óê*'nú�)�ð�� ê�ç�9{úQç{ìké!ð{ø!øüné!ç{ïnì&' � � ürý �+�g/@ç{ïnè�ê*'núfìkæné�é!úkïrê7ëcï+üné�çLïnì&' � � ü�ý ¡C� ��7 'nú�ìbæné!é�úkïrê)�úbìdê�ð{颡�� �0¡£�sÕ � � �Õø�çbê�ëíø!ûnúbø.¤mëíé!ì&','Óð�@¦¥íøìbæné!é�úkïrê��cç� �m¤ Ù Á��ÕîOðLé. �/c S'nëíì&'7ëíøé!ú�-né!úbø!úkïrêrúkè�çLø

�N¡C��Õ~üné!ç{ïnì&' � �íúkç�)núkø��C ¶� �N¡C��Õ~üné!ç{ïnì&' � úbïrê�úké�ø¢�� � l�Æ�0�¬�3�X�l�

� �0�¬���§¦�S���

7 'núB)�ð�� ê�ç�9{úA)�úkì¯ê�ðLéG��� �0�+� Õ � � �mø!çbêrëcø�ûnúkø1¤mëcé�ì&','nð�@b¥cø�)�ð�� ê�ç=9Lú��cç� �m¤ É Á��îOðLé�/M/zú+��-né!úbø!ø!úbè ç{ø�ê('Óú�ú1��ëíø§êrúkïnìbúÈð{îùç¤-Yðbê�úbï�êrëcç=� /�� ó�¨åø!ænì&'þê('Óçbê /W�X��/���îOðLé�Í��� ç{ïnè��W�Æ� /�©S� /��ÁîOðLéQú1)núké§ý üné�çLïnì&' � � �0ªF�Z�!�X� �n7 'Óúkï,/�ê('nú�-�ð� Ìúké�§úbïnúké09bý���ìkðLïnø�æ,��úkè+ëcï7ê*'núþú��cúbìdê�é�ëcìbç���ïnú¯êU �ð{él%� Që ê(' ìbæné!é�úkïrêfø!ðLæÓé!ìkú� ��,ó%�åëíø

w

Page 7: 東京工業大学shioura/papers/quadML.pdf! " # $&%(' )+*,' -.)0/.$ 1 $&2 3547698;:&)&= 8@? = 8A)&' ->$CB DFEHG;I>J>KLI>MONQPSRUT>VWV.XYVAZ []\!ZWV>G!^ I>MO_`V>\FPaRb_cNb\aRdN

é!ú�-né!úbø!úkïrêrúkè�çLøñ��� ���� �Èëíï�� � �7« �� ���c¡ ñ� Õ7¡Fø�çbê�ëíø!ûÓúkøQ¤ Ù Á îOðLé§ \ ��

S'núké�úkçLø�ê('ÓúS-Yð� �úbé»ìbðLïnø�æ,��úkè: Që ê('Ã-Yðbê�úbï�êrëcç=�"/¤� ó � ëíøÕé!ú"-Óé!úkø�úkïrê�úbè�çLø'.�0/M��� �Èëíï�� � �7« �� �e� �

ñ� ÕN��ø!çbêrëcø�ûnúkøQ¤ É Á¬îOðLé¦/M ��

� êþìbçLï üYúÈøl'nð� Qï�ê*'nçbêþñ+ëíø�äaænçLèÓé!çbêrëcì ? $�ìbðLï*)�ú+�åçLïÓèB' ëíø¹äaænç{èné!çbêrëcì�Á,$�ìkð{ï()nú1� �? ðLé�úkð�)�úbél/kê('Óëcø�ìkð{ïnø§êré!ænì¯ê�ëíðLï� Që ê('mïnð{ï,�cëíïnúbçLé�é!úbø!ëíø§ê�ð{é!øný�ëcú��cènø\9Lúbïnúké�ç����§ïÓðLïnäaænçLèné�çbê�ëíì"�? $çLïnèÃÁ,$�ìbðLï*)�ú1� îOæÓïnìdêrëcðLïÓø<¬�ø!úbú¤u ����x � ­à8áµß,âªãFäåÜ Ú�a�® � ï�u ��� / � {�x ëÂê¹ëíø»ø0'nð� Qï¼ê('nçUê@ê�ðbêrç��c �úbë29='�êrúkè¼êrçLé!èÓëcïnúbø!øø!ì&'núbènæ,�íëcïc9-né!ð{ü,�cú���ø\ Që ê('3'Óë29�'���æ,� ê�ë#-,�íëcìbëÂê]ý7ìkç{ïÔüYú»é�úkîOðLé0��æ,�íçbê�úbèþçLø�ëcïrêrú"9Lúbén-né�ð�9Lé�ç���ø� Që ê('äaænçLèné�çbê�ëíì�ðLü|Àdúbìdêrë>)nú�îOænïnì¯ê�ëíðLïnøl/� S'núké�ú�ø!æÓì&'­äaænç{èné!çbêrëcì�îOænïnì¯ê�ëíðLïnøþçLé�úz9Lë)�úbï ürýìkðSú"Ä�ìkëíúkïrê���çbê�é�ëcìbúkø � � �g��� � �m¯ �<� U ðLîÎê*'númîOðLél�

�g��� �J°G± D ² � �m¯ �<� �����0�����Ã�

îOðLéùø�ð���ú¦° �·� °�ñ �´³£³£³,� ° ô �,7 'nëíø�øl'nð� Qø&ê('Óçbêùê('Óú�äaænçLèné�çbê�ëíì@îOænïnì¯ê�ëíðLïnø0ê�é�úkçbêrúkèëcïªu ��� / � {�x çLé!ú ? $�ìkð{ï()nú1� îOænïÓìdê�ëíðLïnø@ð�)núkéùê('núCëíïrê�ú�9Lúké��íçbê!êrëcìbú:�§ø�úkú £ úkì¯ê�ëíðLשׂ�� � ­

j ó ÜQÞrà\ä Ü*Þ

Ï úÌènúkø�ìké!ëíüYú@ê*'nú8��çLëíï�ê('núbðLé!ú���ø@ðLîÓê('nëíø�-nç�-Yúké �C7 'núB-Óé!ðSðLîOø�çLé�ú89Lë)�úbïfëíï £ úbìdê�ëíðLïw �µ s�¶ ·;ôC÷W{"ø"÷�ùKúX6�25476&û"ü�8:9<;<¸l2.ǹ476&û"ü�8:9<;»º�ôiüx6(ùKú1û"üMó

µ s�¶Ws�¶ 25476&û"ü�8:9<;»º!ô|üx6(ùKú1û"üMóÏ úÌûné!ø êCìkð{ïnø!ëíènúké@ç�øl-Yúkìkëíç���ìkçLø�ún S'núké�ú�ê('nú»îOænïnì¯ê�ëíðLï»'Fëcø�ènúkûnïÓúkèFð�)�úké9ê('nú�úbïrê�ëíé!úøl-nç{ìkúCóÈô¢ò

'.�0/M��� �� /����./ �Y/¤��ó ô �l� � { ��� �

7 'núìkðSú"Ä�ìkëíúkïrêA�ÈçUê�é!ë�fðLîYø!ænì&'¼ç¹äaænç{èné!çbêrëcì�Á,$�ìbðLï*)�ú+�7îOæÓïnìdêrëcðLï:'nçLø�çQø!ë#��-,�cúø!ë#9Lï-nçbê�ê�úké�ï �¿

Page 8: 東京工業大学shioura/papers/quadML.pdf! " # $&%(' )+*,' -.)0/.$ 1 $&2 3547698;:&)&= 8@? = 8A)&' ->$CB DFEHG;I>J>KLI>MONQPSRUT>VWV.XYVAZ []\!ZWV>G!^ I>MO_`V>\FPaRb_cNb\aRdN

gih\ÜaÞYÝgÜQâ j�a§Ù�n�¼ ôµ÷W{"ø�÷�ùKúX6ez1ôiüx6(ùKú1û"ü3'fòYó ô õ ó¾½(ú�8:9lüïõ<|²� { �Ð� ��¿�ú1ù0�Ã� �À� ôú¯óM25476&û"ü�8:9<;�úuz�÷"üx{¤û"üxw |:úuzÁ ������� �K�&�0�����3�p�8��ï�i�l� ô

���M� Á ��� � � ���n���Ã��� � { � � �

` Ý>Þ&Þ�æca �åÁ\½ � �@ëcøÕúbäSæÓë>)(ç��íúkïrêê�ð�ê('nú³�íð(ìbç���ø!æÓü,��ð(ènæc�cçLé�ëÂê]ý�ò

'.�0/1*KIÂ� � �A*L'.�0/H*#ÃÄ� � � � '.�0/M�A*L'.�0/H*�Il� � *#Ã�� � ��0/3� ó ô ���&�0�s���3���8��ï�^�1I��Xà ��� ��� S'nëíì&'fìbçLïÁüYúÌé!ú+ Qé!ë ê!êrúkïFçLøzê*'nú�îOðLé0�Èúbé;-né�ð�-Yúké§ê]ý7ëíïv� { � � �<¬.�TÁ�½ � ��ëíø�úkäaænë)(ç��cúbïrê@ê�ðê('nú³�íçbê!êrúkéÕëíï�� { � � � � ­ãÌø�ëíøp Ìú"�#��%aïnð� Qï,/�çLïrý¹��çbêré!ë�åø�çbê�ëíø!îgý�ëíï,9ï� { � � ��ëíø�-YðLø!ë ê�ë)�úFø�ú"��ëcèÓúkûnïnë ê�úªu � / ��y�x �7 'núké�úkîOðLé�ú"/näaænç{èné!çbêrëcì�Á,$}ìkðLï*)�ú+�FîOænïnì¯ê�ëíðLïnø�ðLîLê*'nú@îOðLél� � { �Ð� �zçLé!ú�ìkðLï*)�ú+�fîOænïnì¯ê�ëíðLïnøëcïFê('núÈðLé�ènëcïÓçLé§ý²ø!úbïnø!ú �n¡ ðbê�ëíï,9�ê('nçbêQê('Óú���çbêré!ë�ï� ø!çUê�ëíø!îgý�ëcïc9Ø� { � � �QëcøQø!ëíï,9Læc�cçLé0/ë � ú � /�é!ç{ï,%�� � ÿ�� � /c ÌúQèÓúkïnðbêrú

Ť� Æô �M�

��� �B� ô Õ~îOæÓïnìdêrëcðLï�� { �Ð� �@ð�)núké@óÈôÔëíø¶Á,$}ìkðLï*)�ú+���Cé!ç{ï,%��ì�²ÿ�� �  ��Ť� Æ

ô �M���� �B� ô Õ~îOæÓïnìdêrëcðLï�� { �Ð� �@ð�)núké@óÈôÔëíø¶Á,$}ìkðLï*)�ú+�� ��

Ï úmïnú+�aê�é�ú1)núkç��nê('ÓúQüc�cðSì&%*$�ènëíç�9LðLïÓç���ø§êré!ænì¯ê�æné�ú¹ðLî\��çbê�é�ëcìbúkøëcï Å �gih\ÜaÞYÝgÜQâ j�aKÚ�n �Ã÷�ù�ø_ú�; � �Ç� ô õy9£wKû"ü�½(ó²ùTû Å úuz�÷"üx{»û"üxw |vúuz�� ú¯óv÷»õ£wKû£6<È£4{"ú1÷N½iû"ü\÷WwF�Ã÷�ù�ø_ú�;1¿QsÌøOs¯ù�s,ó^ûN�39FöC÷"øtù�ú1ùKú1û"ü�ûXz;���.�:ÕW~s� � � � �*�*�"��� �  ÃûXz���ó&ô�6<��ùY�!÷�ù�Æu>��� x ��Å ��~s� � � � �*�*�*�¢� � �ZtÄ¿Ä�l9løN9 � �²ÿ�� é�çLï,%;��sÉ úbé!ú"/Îç¹ü,�cðSì&%*$�ènëíç�9Lð{ïnç��M��çbê�é�ë>�z�¾ � é � ê � çÆ�§ø�ænü,�0-nçLé§êrëÂêrëcð{ï¤�����:Õ+~s� � � � �*�*�*�¢� �  ðLîµ����úkç{ïnø�ê*'nçbê»ç��#��úkïrê�é�ëcúbø�ëíï¤� çLé!úÕúbäSæÓç��Lê�ðS�kúké�ð¹ú+��ìkú"-.êCîOðLé&ê('ÓðLø!úÕëíï3-né�ëcïnìbë2-Óç��ø!ænüc�ÈçUê�é!ëíìkúbø8�Æu>��� x ��~�� � � � �*�*�*�¢� � � �Ï úÌê*'núkï�ìbðLïnø�ëcènúbémçLï Á,$�ìkð{ï()nú1�¬îOænïnìdêrëcð{ï ð{î�ê*'nú�9Lúbïnúké�ç��ùîOðLé0� � � ��� �Ìëíï*)�ð��)�ëcï,9fçø!ænüÓøl-nçLìbú»$ �gih\ÜaÞYÝgÜQâ j�aYj 2�9(ù�� �Ê� ô t�÷"üx{ $ � ó ô õy9Ø÷�w ú¯üx9&÷"ø²ó&ôµõló�öC÷W6y9£sBËl�l9lü�tÃ÷¼ ôµ÷W{"ø�÷�ùKúX6�z1ôiüx6(ù�ú1û"ü3'�ò&óÈôFõ óÌ(²�+*1,¹ ªûN8:9lø[$�te½(ú�8:9lü¾õ<|v� � ��� �<tnú¯ói25476&û"ü�8:9<;úuzv÷"üx{Íû"üxw |»úuzÍ$ � øl-ÓçLïM�W� Ux} Õ.~ � � � � �"�*�*�¢�CÎQ Àz"û"ø�ó^ûN�39�öC÷"øtù�ú1ùKú1û"ü����.� Õ~�� � � � �*�*�"���CÎQ ÍûXz�� ÷"üx{ªùY�l9�Ï1÷N½£½(ør9нi÷�ù9y{lÑ1�Ã÷�ù�ø_ú�; � ���xÒ�{W9Ó\üx9y{²õ<| Á �ÕÔ¶���� U } �Õ� UxÖ Á ��� õy9£wKû"ü�½(ó�ùTû ÅetÄ¿Ä�l9lør9�ÎS� ènë#��$ s

y

Page 9: 東京工業大学shioura/papers/quadML.pdf! " # $&%(' )+*,' -.)0/.$ 1 $&2 3547698;:&)&= 8@? = 8A)&' ->$CB DFEHG;I>J>KLI>MONQPSRUT>VWV.XYVAZ []\!ZWV>G!^ I>MO_`V>\FPaRb_cNb\aRdN

µ s�¶Wsu× 2 Ç 476&û"ü�8:9<;-º�ôiüx6(ùKú1û"üMó

Ø çLø�úkè�ðLï�ê('núQènúbûnïnë ê�ëíðLï�ðLî§Á Ç $�ìbðLï*)�ú+�0ë ê]ý�/ 7 'núkðLé�ú"��ø { �Ð� / { � � /�çLïnè { � { çLüYð�)�ú¹îOðLéÁ,$�ìkð{ï()nú1��îOænïnìdêrëcð{ïnø@ìkçLïÁúbçLø!ë#� ý�üYú�é!ú�-,'né�çLø!úbèfîOð{é;Á.ÇË$�ìkð{ï()nú1��îOæÓïnìdêrëcðLïÓø�çLø�îOð��#�íð& Qø �Ï úmènúbïnðbêrú

Å Ç �ÙÆô �M�

���ì�B� ô Õ{îOænïnì¯ê�ëíðLï�� { ��� �@ð�)�úbé@ó ô ëcø�Á Ç $�ìkð{ï()nú1�<�mé�çLï,%;� �+ÿ� ��Å Ç �ÙÆ

ô �M����ì�B� ô Õ{îOænïnì¯ê�ëíðLï�� { ��� �@ð�)�úbé@ó�ôÔëcø�Á.ÇÈ$�ìkð{ï()nú1�< ��

gih\ÜaÞYÝgÜQâ j�aY®�n�¼ ôµ÷W{"ø�÷�ùKúX6ez1ôiüx6(ùKú1û"ü3'fòYó�ô¼õ ó¾½(ú�8:9lüïõ<|²� { �Ð� ��¿�ú1ù0�Ã� �À� ôú¯óM2 Ç 476&û"ü�8:9<;�úuz�÷"üx{¤û"üxw |�úuz

Á ������� �K�M�&�0�����3�p�8����i��� ô���M� Á ������� �K�M�n�����l� � { � { �

7 'nëíøzê('núbðLé!ú��÷øl'nð� Qøzê*'nçbê�ê('nú»ìkðSú"Ä�ìkëíúkïrê³��çbêré!ë�7ð{î&ç�äaænçLèné�çbê�ëíìAÁ.ÇË$�ìbðLï*)�ú+��îOænïnì+$ê�ëíðLï7ëíøïnðbê('Óëcï,9¼ünæ~ê¹çÔèÓëcç�9{ðLïnç��#�ÂýQ$}ènð���ëcïÓçLïrê�ø ýC����údêré!ëíì ? $��ÈçUê�é!ë� ��7 'nëcøp��úkçLïnø0/ëcïv-nçLé ê�ëíìkæ,�íçLé0/�ê*'nçbê¼çfäSæÓçLèné!çUê�ëíì:Á.ÇÈ$�ìbðLï*)�ú1�²îOænïÓìdê�ëíðLï ìkðLëíïnìbëcènúbø¶ Që ê(' ç�¦Cëíé!ëíì&',�íúdêîOðLél� ðLî�ûÓïnëÂêrú�ènë#��úkïnø�ëcðLï �§¡ ðbêrúê*'nçbê�ç{ï�ý ø§ý�����údêré!ëíì:��çbêré!ë�¬ QëÂê*'Ôê('nú�-Óé!ð�-Yúké ê]ý� { � { �@ëíø�-�ðLø�ëÂêrë>)nú¹ø�ú"��ëíènúkûnïÓëÂêrúÆ�§ìbî � u � / ��y=x � �� ï�-ÓçLé!ç��#�íú"�c Që ê(' 7 'núkðLé�ú"��ø { � � çLïnè { � { �úS'nç�)�ú@ê('ÓúQîOð=�2�íð� Qëcï,9 �gih\ÜaÞYÝgÜQâ j�aYÚ�n �Ã÷�ùKø_ú�;�� �Û� ô õy9£wKû"ü�½(ó�ùTû Å Ç úuz¬÷"üx{ªû"üxw | úuzs� ú¯ó�÷�õ£wKû£6<È£4{"ú1÷N½iû"ü\÷Wwx�Ã÷�ùKø_ú�;�¿QsÌøOs¯ù�snó^ûN�39:ó&ôµõTöC÷"øtùKú1ù�ú1û"ü¹���.�¾Õ�~�� � � � �"�*�*�¢� �  ¹ûXz:� ó&ô�6<�ù0�!÷�ù��Æu>��� x �ÌÅ ��~ï� � � � � �*�"�*��� �  ���÷"üx{Ã�ÆuË� ò� �M� �.� x �TÅ�Ç�t�¿Ä�l9lør9 � �ÿÃ�åé!çLïc%���s

gih\ÜaÞYÝgÜQâ j�aYÜ 2�9(ù�� �Ê� ô t�÷"üx{ $ � ó ô õy9Ø÷�w ú¯üx9&÷"ø²ó&ôµõló�öC÷W6y9£sBËl�l9lü�tÃ÷¼ ôµ÷W{"ø�÷�ùKúX6�z1ôiüx6(ù�ú1û"üÍ'ÎûN8:9lø»$�te½(ú�8:9lü�õ<|v� � ��� �<t·ú¯ói2 Ç 476&û"ü�8:9<;:úuz:÷"üx{Ãû"üxw |ÆúuzM$ �øl-nç{ï��W� Ux} ÕÝ~Æ� � � � �*�*�*�¢�CÎQ iz"û"øXó^ûN�398ó&ôCõTöC÷"øtù�ú1ùKú1û"ü����.�¬ÕÝ~¤� � � � �*�"�*���NÎi vûXzA�÷"üx{zùY�l9�Ï1÷N½£½(ør9нi÷�ù9y{lÑ��Ã÷�ùKø_ú�; �Ö�_�xÒ�{W9Ó\üx9y{zõ<| Á �ÕÔ§� ��� U�} �<� U Ö Á ��� õy9£wKû"ü�½(óù©û Å Ç tÄ¿Ä�l9lør9�ÎX� ènë#��$ s

Å

Page 10: 東京工業大学shioura/papers/quadML.pdf! " # $&%(' )+*,' -.)0/.$ 1 $&2 3547698;:&)&= 8@? = 8A)&' ->$CB DFEHG;I>J>KLI>MONQPSRUT>VWV.XYVAZ []\!ZWV>G!^ I>MO_`V>\FPaRb_cNb\aRdN

µ su× ·;ôC÷W{"ø"÷�ùKúX6��3476&û"ü�8:9<;<¸l� Ç 476&û"ü�8:9<;iº!ôiüx6(ù�ú1û"üMó

µ su×ls�¶ ��Ç�476&û"ü�8:9<;»º!ôiüx6(ù�ú1û"üMóÏ ú»ûné!ø êCìbðLïnø!ëíènúbé�ç�ø0-�úbìkëíç��0ìbçLø!ú� S'núké�úÐê('nú»îOænïnì¯ê�ëíðLïÁñ7ëíø�ènúbûnïnúbèÁð&)núkézê*'núÌúbïrê�ëíé!úøl-nç{ìkúCóÈô¢ò

ñ��� ���� �� � �� �� ó ô ��� � { � ¥��

Ï úmènúbïnðbêrú

Þ Ç � Æô �M�

� �B� ô Õ~îOænïÓìdê�ëíðLï�� { � ¥��@ð�)�úbé@ó ô ëcø ? Ç $�ìbðLï*)�ú+���Cé!çLïc% � ÿ� ��Þ Ç � Æ

ô �M�� �B� ô Õ~îOænïÓìdê�ëíðLï�� { � ¥��@ð�)�úbé@ó�ôÔëcø ? ÇÈ$�ìbðLï*)�ú+�� ��

` Ý>Þ�ã�Þ�Þrâ Ürâ ÞÎÛ�jba�ß�§ë#� n ü�|%�Ã÷�ù�ø_ú�; �BÞ Ç.ú¯ó;öCû"ó&ú1ùKú�8:9»{W9Ó\üMú1ù9£s�§ëíë2� n ü�|à�Ã÷�ùKø_ú�; � Þ Ç ú¯ó;öCû"ó&ú1ù�ú�8:9¶óo9<�súX{W9Ó\üMú1ù�9£sÁ�údêÌñfòSóÈô�õ ó üYúð{îSê('ÓúîOð{él� � { � ¥=�< Që ê('ÈçQïnðLïnø�ëcï,9{æ,�cç{é �B� ô � Ï ú� Që#�2�Îøl'Óð& ëcï 7 'núkð{é!ú"� { � y ê('nçUê ? ÇÌ$}ìkðLï*)�ú+��ëÂê]ý ðLîHø�ænì&'�ñ�ëcøì&'nçLé�çLìdêrúké�ë2�búkè�ürýFê('númîOð��#�íð& Qëíï,9-né!ð=-�úbé§ê�ëíúkø �

= ë Ç é1à��à� Ó > �M \�0´ � ó ô /§�M�Æ�÷ø!æ,-c- Ó �� ²�¾´��l/ D �ï�÷ø!æ,-c- � �� ²�¹´��á(»� �  �/D!� Ñ � òñ��K ��A*åñ��K´C� Ñ ñ��� 3�

!�� � ��� � �0�A*åñ��K´»*

!��� � ��� � �l�X��� !

�¹� � � ! � x ���©� { � «��= ë Ç é1à��à� Óâ > � �g�\Ñ ��ëcïp� � � �Èëíï�<�cã¹äÕåÕåOæ �èç � � �^�   �K�M ²� ó ô �µ�M�n� ø!æ,-c-!Ó§�� ��0���= ë Ç é1à��à� Óâ é ó > � �^��Ñ �Èëíïp� � ����ëíï�<� Ueé � ��� � �g�   ���M �� ó ô �<�M�n� ø�æ,-,-!Ó§�K ��l�l�= è Ç é�Ú7ê�ë�> ëíøÕïnðLïnø�ëcï,9{æ,�cç{é»çLïÓè � � ø�çbê�ëíø!ûÓúkøs� { � { �l/

S'núké�ú �g� ���n���Ã�ÕènúkïnðUê�úkø�ê('Óú��T$;ê*'fìbð��íæ,��ï�)núkìdêrðLéðLî �gih\ÜaÞYÝgÜQâ j�aYì 2�9(ù&ñÍõy9S÷ ¼ ôC÷W{"ø�÷�ù�úX6bz1ô|üx6(ùKú1û"ü�ûN8:9løó ô ½(ú�8:9lü�õ<|¬� { � ¥=��¿�ú1ù0� �� ô sQËl�l9lü�t

�3Þ Ç íïî � ? ÇÈ$ ��� Ù Ó � íïî � ? ÇÈ$ ��� Ù Óð �íïî � ? ÇÌ$ �¢� Ù Óð $Õñp� íïî �åÁ§ÇÈ$ � ¡�É �Cs

� �

Page 11: 東京工業大学shioura/papers/quadML.pdf! " # $&%(' )+*,' -.)0/.$ 1 $&2 3547698;:&)&= 8@? = 8A)&' ->$CB DFEHG;I>J>KLI>MONQPSRUT>VWV.XYVAZ []\!ZWV>G!^ I>MO_`V>\FPaRb_cNb\aRdN

Ù ð���üÓëcïnëíï,9 7 'núkð{é!ú"� { � y QëÂê*' 7 'ÓúkðLé�ú"� { � ¥¼ý�ëíú"�íènø�ê('núÁîOð��#�íð& Qëíï,9�é!ú��cçUê�ëíðLïnøl'Óë2-ü�ú¯êU �úbúkïÀÅ Ç çLïnè[Þ Ç �gih\ÜaÞYÝgÜQâ j�aYò º.û"øX� �KÅ�Ƕ÷"üx{ �ÀÞ Çótá¿Q9M�!÷N8:9B�[� � �LÞ Ç¶÷"üx{ � � �KÅ�Ç sô 9lüx6y9<tXùY�l9�ú¯ü�8:9lø¢óo9<4 �Ã÷�ùKø_ú�;Æør9£wK÷�ù�ú1û"üMóy��úÌö ö!ø�ûN8(úX{W9lóÃ÷vû"üx9<4¢ù©ûN4¢û"üx9�6&û"ø_ør9ló�öCû"üx{W9lüx6y9õy9(ù0¿Q9y9lü�Å�Ç�÷"üx{.Þ ÇõsÏ ú�ê('núbïfìbðLïnø�ëcènúbéHê('núÌìkçLø�ú; S'núké�ú�ê('nú�ìbð(ú�Ä�ìkëíúkïrêS��çbê�é�ë>� ëcø;-�ðLø�ø!ëíü,� ý�ø!ëíï,9Læc�cçLé �Ï ú�èÓúkïnðbêrú�ü�ýÎ� ? Ç $ ��� Ù ��ê*'nús-né!ð=-�úbé§ê]ý � ? Ç $ ��� Ù Ó �; QëÂê*'þê('nú�ø ê�é!ëíìdê¼ëíïnúkäaænç=�cë ê]ý4 Ñ 6 ëíï�� { � «��Õé!ú�-,�cç{ìkúkè�ürý çLï7ëíïnúkäaænç=�cë ê]ýì4 � 6=� Ï úQènúkûÓïnú¤� ? Ç $ ��� Ù ð �ÕîOé!ð�� � ? Ç $��� Ù Óð �ëíïfçÈø�ë2��ë#�cç{é� Ìç}ý �gih\ÜaÞYÝgÜQâ j�a§Ù ®�2�9(ù»ñ õy9 ÷ ¼ ôµ÷W{"ø�÷�ùKúX6iz1ôiüx6(ùKú1û"ü ûN8:9løÁó�ô�½(ú�8:9lüìõ<|¾� { � ¥��à¿�ú1ù0� �B� ô sQËl�l9lü�t

� Þ Ç íïî � ? ÇÌ$ �¢� Ù �§íàî � ? ÇÌ$ ��� Ù ð �£sÏ úCïÓú1�aê¹é!ú1)núkç��nê*'núCø§êré!ænì¯ê�æné�úQð{îÎê*'nú:�T-YðLø!ø�ëcüc�Âý ø�ëcï,9{æ,�cç{él�@ìkðSú"Ä�ìbëcúbï�ê���çbê�é�ë>� �� ô ê('nçUêQènúkûnïÓúkøÌç�äaænçLèÓé!çbêrëcì ? ÇÈ$�ìbðLï*)�ú1� îOæÓïnìdêrëcðLïfð�)�úbéÕóÈô �gih\ÜaÞYÝgÜQâ j�a§ÙÎÙ�n �Ã÷�ùKø¢ú�; ��� ô õy9£wKû"ü�½(óÆùTû Þ Ç úuz:÷"üx{�û"üxw |Ãúuz:ù0�l9lør9ï9<;(ú¯ó^ù�÷ó&ôµõTöC÷"øtùKú1ù�ú1û"ü²���.��ÕW~:� � � � �*�*�*�¢� �  ²ûXzp� ÷"üx{¤÷"ü � � � �Ã÷�ù�ø_ú�; �BÞ Ç§ó&ô�6<�ù0�!÷�ù

�g��� � � �ÕÔ��K�n�����t�p�s�»�.ÔT�-~,�Cöµ��� � � � �*�"�*��� �  ����� �0û�ù0�l9løc¿�ú¯óo9l�l�

¿Ä�l9lør9 � � é�çLï,% sÏ úÌûnïnç��#�Âý7ìkð{ïnø!ëíènúkéHê*'núA9{úkïnúbé!ç���îOðLél�­� � � � �Ðëcï*)nð��>)�ëíï,9�ç�ø!æÓünøl-nç{ìkúH� � Ï úÌènúkïnðUê�úürý Þ ê*'núÕø!údêÌðLîYø§ý�����údê�é�ëcìp��çbê�é�ëcìbúkø ø�ænì&'Qê*'nçbê�ê('Óúäaænç{èné!çbêrëcìîOænïnì¯ê�ëíðLïÈðLîaê*'núîOð��#�cð� Qëíï,9¼îOð{él� ëíø ? $�ìbðLï*)�ú+�0ò

ñ��� ��M� �� � Î�� ��ó ô �� n�T����� � �l�*1, �§ðbê*'núkéå Qëcø�ú*��� � { � w �

gih\ÜaÞYÝgÜQâ j�a§Ù�Ú 2�9(ù �÷� ô t¬÷"üx{L� � óÈôìõy9ª÷Kw ú¯üx9&÷"ø�ó&ôµõló�öC÷W6y9£sSËl�l9lü�t¤÷¼ ôµ÷W{"ø�÷�ùKúX6¢z1ô|üx6(ùKú1û"ü�ñ¹ûN8:9løH�BtĽ(ú�8:9lüØõ<|�� � � � �<t§ú¯óM��Ç�476&û"ü�8:9<;�úuz�÷"üx{¤û"üxw |:úuz�ù0�l9lør99<;(ú¯ó^ù�ó:÷Só&ôµõTöC÷"øtùKú1ù�ú1û"ü²���.�:ÕW~s� � � � �*�*�"��� �  ²ûXz�� ó&ô�6<� ù0�!÷�ù

� ���" �� ó ô Õ� n�©�.�t��� � ��~s� � � � �*�*�*�¢� � �� �� � { � ¿�� uË�.� x � Þ �~:� � � � �*�"�*��� � ��� uË�pò Ó � x � Þ Ç �

���

Page 12: 東京工業大学shioura/papers/quadML.pdf! " # $&%(' )+*,' -.)0/.$ 1 $&2 3547698;:&)&= 8@? = 8A)&' ->$CB DFEHG;I>J>KLI>MONQPSRUT>VWV.XYVAZ []\!ZWV>G!^ I>MO_`V>\FPaRb_cNb\aRdN

�g��� � �g�Yø>� � �g���Ðø � �g�YøË�ùø�����0�ùú!���.�=�p�^�1�Oú!���.Ôå�i~,�CöC��� � � � �"�*�*�¢� �  ��»~���´ö¯��� � { � y ��g��� � �^�Ì�ùø ���n���pò Ó � ���^�0� ú �����=�i~:�»� � � � �*�*�"�¢� �  ���� � { �#Å �¿Ä�l9lør9A�Aò Ó � ���Ì ò� �M� �.�z÷"üx{ � �²ÿÃ�åènë#���_só ÜQâ�ßnÝüû�j�a§Ù+j � îùê('Óúþø!ænüÓøl-nçLìbú�� ëcøs9Lë)�úbï ü�ýì� { � ¿��¹çLïnè�ê('nú3�ÈçUê�é!ë� ��� ôø!çbêrëcø�ûnúkø�� { � y �@ç{ïnèª� { �#Å �l/Sê('núbï�ê*'núCäaænçLèné�çbê�ëíìmîOænïnìdêrëcð{ï7ñ 9Lë)�úbï�ürýï� � � � �@ø!çbêrëcø�ûnúkø

ñ��� ����ò Ó �� �M� �� nu>��� x � u>��� x nuË�.� x �K ������� � { �Ð� � �

7 'aænøl/nê('ÓúQìbð(ú�Ä�ìkëíúkïrês��çbêré!ë� ëcøÕú�@�úbìdê�ë)�ú��Âý ü,�íð(ì&%*$}ènëcç=9LðLïnç�� � ­

µ su×lsu× �3476&û"ü�8:9<;»º�ôiüx6(ùKú1û"üMó½ÎðLé@çLïrý²��çbê�é�ë>� �3� ô /c Ìú¹èÓúkûnïnú Ç�� � � Ç��� �·�B� ô+� � ürý

� Ç��� � �g��� � �g� ô � � ô � * � ôbô �K�&�0�s����p�kÿ§ ����

Ï úmènúbïnðbêrú

Þ � Æô �M�

� ��� ô Õ~îOæÓïnìdêrëcðLï�� { � w �@ëíø ? $�ìbðLï*)�ú+���Cé!çLïc% Ç �+ÿ�� �  ��Þ � Æ

ô �M�� ��� ô Õ~îOæÓïnìdêrëcðLï�� { � w �@ëíø ? $�ìbðLï*)�ú+�� ��

� ê¹ëcøÕúkç{ø§ýþêrð¼ø�úkúmîOé!ð��,ê('númènúbûnïnë ê�ëíðLï�ð{î ? ÇÈ$�ìbðLï*)�ú+�0ë ê]ýFê('nçUê �BÞ íïî Ç ��Þ Ç � � Þ íïî Ç � Þ Ç � � { �Ð�=� �

¡ ðbêrúmç��cø�ð�ê('nçbê¹îOðLé@ç���çbêré!ë� � � �g��� �·�B� ô Ó � 9Lë)�úbï7ürý�g��� � �g��� ëcî��&�1�����3� �^�Ì� � � ðbê*'núkéå Qëcø�ú(� � { �Ð� � �

�úS'nç�)�ú �BÞ Ç íàî ��Þ � � Þ Ç íïî � Þ � � { �Ð� { �

� �

Page 13: 東京工業大学shioura/papers/quadML.pdf! " # $&%(' )+*,' -.)0/.$ 1 $&2 3547698;:&)&= 8@? = 8A)&' ->$CB DFEHG;I>J>KLI>MONQPSRUT>VWV.XYVAZ []\!ZWV>G!^ I>MO_`V>\FPaRb_cNb\aRdN

½ÎðLé@ç�äSæÓçLèné!çUê�ëíìQîOæÓïnìdêrëcðLï�ñFòÓó ô õöóý(��+*1,¹ ÈðLî�ê('ÓúQîOð{él� � { � w �l/&ìbðLïnø�ëcènúbé�ê*'núîOð��#�cð� Qëíï,9�-Óé!ð�-Yúké ê�ëíúkø!ò= ëìé1à��%� Ó > �M \�0´¬� óÈôQ/,�M�n� ø!æc-,- Ó �� ¤�ª´��l/ D ��� ø!æ,-,-l�.�� Æ�v´C�0/ D

!� Ñ�� ò

ñ��K ��A*åñ��K´C� Ñ ñ��� 3�!�� � ��� � �0�A*åñ��K´»*

!��� � ��� � �l� ���

!�¹� � � ! � x ���

= ëìé1à��%� Óâ > �� �g��Ñ ��ëcï�Õ�yãóäÕå<åOæ �èç � �� �g� ���M ²� ó ô ���M�n� ø!æc-,- Ó �� ��0���

Ï úÈènúbïnðbê�úÈürý�� ? $ �¢� Ù ð �Õê*'nú�-Óé!ð�-Yúké ê]ý�� ? $ �¢� Ù Óð �� Që ê('fê*'núÈø§ê�é�ëcì¯êÁëíïnúkäaænç=�cë ê]ý4 Ñ 6 é!ú"-c�cçLìbúkè�ü�ý�çLï�ëíïnúbäSæÓç��cë ê]ý~4 � 6��gih\ÜaÞYÝgÜQâ j�a§Ù+® 2�9(ù�ñ ò�óÈô õ ó÷(��+*1,¹ Øõy9�÷ ¼ ôC÷W{"ø�÷�ù�úX6�z1ô|üx6(ùKú1û"ü ½(ú�8:9lü õ<|� { � w �Q¿�ú1ù0� �B� ô sQËl�l9lü�t

�§ë#� �BÞ íïî � ? $ �¢� Ù Ó �§íàî � ? $ ��� Ù Óð �<t�§ëíë2� � Þ íàî � ? $ ��� Ù ð �£sÏ úCïÓú1�aê¹é!ú1)núkç��nê*'núCø§êré!ænì¯ê�æné�úQð{îÎê*'nú:�T-YðLø!ø�ëcüc�Âý ø�ëcï,9{æ,�cç{él�@ìkðSú"Ä�ìbëcúbï�ê���çbê�é�ë>� �� ô ê('nçUêQènúkûnïÓúkøÌç�äaænçLèÓé!çbêrëcì ? $}ìkðLï*)�ú+� îOænïnìdêrëcð{ï�ð�)�úbé�óÈô �gih\ÜaÞYÝgÜQâ j�a§Ù+Ú�n �Ã÷�ù�ø_ú�; �K� ô õy9£wKû"ü�½(ó¬ùTû Þ úuz3÷"üx{ û"üxw |�úuzÆùY�l9lør9�9<;(ú¯ó^ùA÷öC÷"øtù�ú1ùKú1û"ü����.�:ÕW~�� � � � �*�*�"��� �  zûXz�� ÷"üx{3÷"ü � � � �Ã÷�ùKø¢ú�; �BÞ ó&ô?6<� ùY�!÷�ù�g��� � � �ÕÔ¶���·�»�.�t�¶������Ôå�-~,�Cöµ��� � � � �*�*�"��� �  ��ZtÄ¿Ä�l9lør9 � �5é!çLï,% sÏ ú�ûnïÓç��2� ý ìbðLïnø�ëcènúbé�ê*'nú�ø§êré!ænì¯ê�æné�ú ð{îQç äaænçLèÓé!çbêrëcì ? $}ìkðLï*)�ú+�,îOænïnì¯ê�ëíðLï5ð{î@ê*'nú9LúkïÓúké!ç=��îOðLél��� � � � � �gih\ÜaÞYÝgÜQâ j�a§Ù+Ü 2�9(ù �÷� ô t¬÷"üx{L� � ó ô õy9ª÷Kw ú¯üx9&÷"ø�ó&ôµõló�öC÷W6y9£sSËl�l9lü�t¤÷¼ ôµ÷W{"ø�÷�ùKúX6�z1ôiüx6(ùKú1û"ü ñ5ûN8:9lø-��tá½(ú�8:9lüïõ<|v� � � � �<t�ú¯ó-�3476&û"ü�8:9<;�úuz�÷"üx{Ãû"üxw |¤úuzsù0�l9lør99<;(ú¯ó^ù�óz÷söC÷"øtùKú1ù�ú1û"üï�����»Õb~Ø� � � � �"�*�*�¢� �  �ûXz�� ó&ô�6<��ù0�!÷�ùB� { � ¿��<t u>��� x � Þ��~�� � � � �*�*�*�¢� � �Zt¶÷"üx{¤� { � y �ZtÄ¿Ä�l9løN9 � �²ÿ�� èÓë2����s

® ��ÞÎÛ�þ�à�ÿ�ßná����sÜaÜ��XÜQÜSÛ­çþà\ßnßzÝgßnÜkâ§á ènédá¢ÞÎÛµí�ÜQá­ßnÛ9ß�ëìédá¢ÞYÛCí!ÜQá î�àzÛ9á�éÜrâ ÞÎÛ\Þ

7 'nú�ìkðLï^Àdæ,9LçLì¯ý�é!ú��cçUê�ëíðLïnøl'Óë2-Qü�ú¯êU �úbúkï¹äSæÓçLèné!çUê�ëíì�ÁM$�Ê�Á.ÇË$�ìkð{ï()nú1��ç{ïnè ? $&Ê ? ÇÌ$}ìkðLï*)�ú+�îOænïnì¯ê�ëíðLïnøëcøëcï*)núkø§êrë29{çbê�úbè�ëcï�ê('nëíøø!úkì¯ê�ëíðLï � ½ÎðLéÕç¼îOæÓïnìdêrëcðLï�ñ�ònóÈô�õ óR(��+*1,¹ �/ �úQènúbûnïnúQñ���òÓó ô õ ó)(z���-,¹ �ürý

ñ � �Y/M��� ø!æc-��N/ � Æ�åñ§�� ��AÕ¢ � ó ô   �Y/¤� ó ô �l�

� {

Page 14: 東京工業大学shioura/papers/quadML.pdf! " # $&%(' )+*,' -.)0/.$ 1 $&2 3547698;:&)&= 8@? = 8A)&' ->$CB DFEHG;I>J>KLI>MONQPSRUT>VWV.XYVAZ []\!ZWV>G!^ I>MO_`V>\FPaRb_cNb\aRdN

7 'núÌê�é�çLïnø�îOðLél��çbêrëcðLï�îOé�ð�� ñ�ê�ðÁñ��ÌëíøCìkç=�2�íúkèþê('Óú»2�9н:9lüx{"øN9Nºb9lüx6<�l9£w�ù�ø�÷"üMóÐz"û"øc�Ã÷N4ù�ú1û"üM/ÎçLïÓè¹ê('núîOænïnì¯ê�ëíðLïÁñ���ëcø�ê('nú»6&û"ü��1ôݽi÷�ù9�ð{î�ñ � Ï úp'nç�)�ú��Añ��0� ��� ñ�îOðLé�ç¹ì��cð{ø!úkèìkðLï*)nú1� îOænïnì¯ê�ëíðLï �<£ úbú3u � ¥�/ � ¿ x îOðLé@ènúdêrçLë#�cøðLï�ê('númìbðLïtÀdæ,9Lç{ìdý�ðLîzìkðLï*)nú1� îOænïnì¯ê�ëíðLïnø �£ æ,-,-YðLø�úCê*'nçbê¼ñ¬ëíømçÁäSæÓçLèné!çUê�ëíìÈìbðLï*)�ú+�+îOænïnìdêrëcð{ï ð�)�úbé1� 9Lë>)núkï ürý � � � � �n Që ê(' ç-�ð{ø!ë ê�ë)�úÁø!ú���ëcènúbûnïnë ê�ú¬��çbê�é�ë>� �§� ô çLïnè¬ç �íëíïnúkçLé�ø!ænünø0-nçLìbúÍ� � óÈô �n7 'núbï,/ê('núFìbðLïtÀdæ,9LçUê�ú['Î��ñ���ëcø�ç�äaænçLèné�çbê�ëíì�ìbðLï*)�ú+�­îOænïnìdêrëcð{ïï9Lë)�úbï ürý � � �Ð� �A Që ê('+ç-�ð{ø!ë ê�ë)�úQø!ú"��ëíènúkûÓïnëÂêrú���çbêré!ë�²� �B� ô çLïnèFç��cëíïnúbçLéÕø!ænünø0-nçLìbúi$Ê�5óÈôÔø!æÓì&'Èê('Óçbê$­� ��� ý %{úbé � ��çLïÓè���� �$ ý %{úké!��� ��/| S'núbé!ú

� � �ª�N/�� ó ô Õ7/ � z� � ���M ²� � ��  � � �5ó ô �l�%{úbé �ª�" ��ó ô Õ z� �   � �3� ô �l�

Ï ú³��ç}ý¤ Qé!ë ê�ú@ê('ÓëcøÕç��íø!ðÈçLøènð�� ñ � � �§çLé09n��ëíïñC� � � ènð�� ñÃ� �§çLé09n��ëíï»ñ � � � � �å¥ ��� �

S'núké�ú�çLé09n��ëíï»ñ ènúkïÓðbê�úbø�ê('nú¹ø!údê�ðLî§��ëcïÓë2��ë#�kúké�øCðLî�ñ � � ï�-nç{é§ê�ëíìkæc�cçLé0/HëíîÄ� � ó ôçLïnè ëcø�-YðLø!ë ê�ë)�úQènúbûnïnë ê�ú"/nê*'núkï�ê('númìkð{ïtÀdæ,9Lçbêrúmñ � ëcøÕú1��-,�íëíìkë ê(� ýà Qé�ëÂê�ê�úbï�çLø

ñ � �Y/M��� �� /�� � � / �0/�� ó ô �l� �å¥ � � �

� s�¶ ��û"ü��1ô:½i÷W6<|��M9(ù0¿Q9y9lü�25476&û"ü�8:9<;(ú1ùY|�÷"üx{1�B476&û"ü�8:9<;(ú1ùY|

Ï ú�ø0'nð� ê('nçUêÔäaænç{èné!çbêrëcì:Á,$&Ê�Á.Ç>$}ìkðLï*)�ú+�²çLïnè ? $&Ê ? ÇÌ$}ìkðLï*)�ú+�+îOænïnì¯ê�ëíðLïnøQçLé!ú�ìkð{ït$Àdæ,9Lçbêrú�ê�ðÈúkçLì&'fðbê*'núkéÕænïnèÓúkéùê('nú³Á�ú"9{úkïnèné�ú ¼ ½Îúbïnì&'nú"��ê�é�çLïnø�îOðLél��çbêrëcðLï �gih\ÜaÞYÝgÜQâ ®�a§Ù�§ë#�à2�9(ù�� �V� ô t�÷"üx{3$ � ó ô õy9z÷�w ú¯üx9&÷"ø3ó&ôµõló�öC÷W6y9£s��zÃ÷ ¼ ôµ÷W{"ø�÷�ùKúX6Mz1ôiüx6(ù�ú1û"ü' ûN8:9løÍ$�t�½(ú�8:9lü�õ<|�� � ��� �<tpú¯óï25476&û"ü�8:9<;_q�ør9ló�öbs¢2.Ç�476&û"ü�8:9<;<votsùY�l9lü~ùY�l9�6&û"ü��1ô:½i÷�ù�9' � òÓó�ô�õ ó)(��+*1,¹ 3ú¯ó:÷ ¼ ôµ÷W{"ø�÷�ùKúX6��B476&û"ü�8:9<;Íq�ør9ló�öbsÂ��Ç�476&û"ü�8:9<;<v�z1ô|üx6(ùKú1û"üxs�§ëíë2��2�9(ù �§� ô t�÷"üx{Í� � óÈôÎõy9Ã÷#w ú¯üx9&÷"ø�ó&ôµõló�öC÷W6y9£s��zÆ÷ ¼ ôC÷W{"ø�÷�ù�úX6�z1ôiüx6(ù�ú1û"üñ�ûN8:9lø[�Bt�½(ú�8:9lü¹õ<|ª� � � � �Zt;ú¯ó»�3476&û"ü�8:9<;Àq�ør9ló�öbs5� Ç�476&û"ü�8:9<;<votBùY�l9lü¹ùY�l9S6&û"ü��1ô:½i÷�ù�9ñ � òÓóÈô�õöóý(��+*1,¹ 3ú¯ó:÷ ¼ ôµ÷W{"ø�÷�ùKúX6.25476&û"ü�8:9<;Íq�ør9ló�öbsÂ2.Ç�476&û"ü�8:9<;<v�z1ô|üx6(ùKú1û"üxs

¡ ðbêrúzê('Óçbê. Ìú�'nç�)�ú@ç=�cé�úkçLè~ýÔø!úbúkï�ê('Óú�úkø�ø!úkïÓìkúÕðLî{ê('Óú�çLüYð�)�ú@ìkð{ïtÀdæ,9LçLì¯ýþëíï 7 'núbðLé!ú��{ �#Å ç{ïnèª�T¥ � � � �C7 'númîOðLél��úké@é�ú1)núkç��íø�ê*'númëcï*)núké!ø�ú1$��ÈçUê�é!ë� é!ú��cçbêrëcð{ïnøl'në#-fü�ú¯êU �úbúkïÈê*'núìkðSú"Ä�ìkëíúkïrê���çbêré!ëíìkúbøÌðLîùäaænç{èné!çbêrëcìXÁ Ç $}ìkðLï*)nú1� çLïnè ? Ç $}ìkðLï*)�ú+�¬îOæÓïnìdêrëcðLïÓøl/9çLïnèÈê*'nú�cçUê!ê�úbé�ø0'nð� Qø�ç7îOænïÓènç���úkïrê�ç=��îOçLì¯ê¹ê*'nçbê�ê*'núÔìbð(ú�Ä�ìkëíúkïrê¬��çbê�é�ëcìbúkø�ð{î�ç�ìkð{ïtÀdæ,9Lçbêrú-nçLëíéÕðLîzäaænç{èné!çbêrëcìmìbðLï*)�ú1� îOænïÓìdê�ëíðLïnøÕçLé�ú�ê('númëíï()núké�ø!ú�ð{îzúbçLì&'�ðUê('núbé �<7 'nú³-né�ð(ðLî9ðLî7 'núkð{é!ú"�º¥ ��� /{êrð¹üYúp9{ë>)núkïÔüYú"�íð� S/�ëíø�ç¹é�çbê('núbéÐø ê�é�çLë29='�êrîOðLéT ÌçLé�èÔçLé09Læ,��úkïrê�ê�ðQünænë#�cèæ,-�ê('nú�ìkðLïtÀdæc9LçLìdýþëcï�ê*'nëcø�üÓçLø!ëíì@ìkçLø�ú@ürý¬��úkçLïnø�ð{î¢ê*'nú@ø§êré!ænì¯ê�æné�úHê('núbðLé!ú���ø�ø�ænì&'�çLø

� ¥

Page 15: 東京工業大学shioura/papers/quadML.pdf! " # $&%(' )+*,' -.)0/.$ 1 $&2 3547698;:&)&= 8@? = 8A)&' ->$CB DFEHG;I>J>KLI>MONQPSRUT>VWV.XYVAZ []\!ZWV>G!^ I>MO_`V>\FPaRb_cNb\aRdN

7 'núkð{é!ú"��ø { � w ç{ïnè { ��� � îOð{é�ê*'nú�9Lúbïnúké�ç��9ìkçLø�ú � Ï ú�ç=�cø�ðþænø!úê('nú¹îOð��2�íð� Qëcïc9²�§úbçLø§ý��îOçLìdê*/nëíïnènëíìkçbêrëcï,9�ê*'nú@ìkðLï^Àdæ,9LçLì¯ýFü�ú¯êU �úbúkï�ÁM$�Ê�Á Ç $�ìkð{ï()nú1�Fç{ïnè ? $&Ê ? Ç $}ìkðLï*)�ú+�¬�íëcïnúbçLéø!ænüÓøl-nçLìbúkø �` Ý>Þ�ã�Þ�Þrâ Ürâ ÞÎÛ�®ba�Ú º.û"ø¶÷�öC÷"ú¯øpûXzáw ú¯üx9&÷"ø�ó&ôµõló�öC÷W6y9ló¦$ � ø0-nçLï��W� Ux} Õ+~:� � � � �"�*�*�¢� �  ÷"üx{S� � �" ¹�­óÈôÍÕ| n�T���t�³� � ��~²� � � � �"�*�*�¢� � �� �{W9Ó\üx9y{�õ<|�÷3ó&ôµõTöC÷"øtùKú1ù�ú1û"ü�����:Õ+~s� � � � �*�*�*�¢� �  ²ûXz¶�3t¢¿Q9Q�!÷N8:9�$­�´� � sÏ úmïnð� -né!ð�)�ú 7 'núbðLé!ú���¥ �Ð� ëíï�ê*'númìkçLø�úmðLî.Á,$�ìbðLï*)�ú+�Í'�çLïnè ? $}ìkðLï*)nú1� ñ �

` Ý>Þ&Þ�æmÞ�æ = âm>�a u Ù çLø!ú � òb$ � óÈôQ/§� ��Å x £ ëcïnìbú�çLél9·��ëcïÄ' �º�WI Ù Õ�Iv�²ó¬ �/ �ú�'nç�)�ú¼ènð��#' � ���" Î�5ó ô Õc n�©�Ã�X� �  fürý~�å¥ ��� �¹ç{ïnè���é!ð=-�ðLø�ëÂêrëcð{ï�¥ � � ��7 'nú-né!ð=-�úbé§ê]ý¹�TÁ�½ � �»ç��cø�ðþë#�:-c�cëíúkø�'��*�K ���� � �"¨ � �© � ��� »�²ènð��#'��+�l/! S'Óúké!ú � � ôëcøS9Lë)�úbï¬ürý uË��³�kÿ§  x � �©�Æu>��³�kÿ�  x � � � ç{ïnè �g� ô � � ô � � � �������Ã� �·£ ëcïÓìkú�Æu>� ³�kÿ�  x �ÛÅ�ÇV/C �ú:'nç�)�ú � Þ ürý 7 'núbðLé!ú�� { �2Å çLïÓè¾� { �Ð� { �l/� S'Óëcì&'Fý0ëíú"�íènøê('nú ? $}ìkðLï*)nú1��ëÂê]ý ðLî�' � �u Ù ç{ø!ú � òÄ$ �÷óÈô�/���� Å x Ø ý 7 'núkð{é!ú"� { � � /0ê*'núké�ú�ú1��ëcø ê�øQç�-ÓçLé§êrëÂêrëcðLïv���.�²Õ~¤� � � � �*�*�"��� �  þð{î�� ø�ænì&'Ôê('nçUê�çLé09n��ëíïÄ'��,øl-ÓçLï��W� U�} ÕÝ~¤� � � � �*�"�*��� �  þçLïnè'.�0/M�8� ò� �M� 'F�|�0/\u>��� x ���0/ª� óÈô��l/C S'núbé!ú-'F�|�0/\u>��� x �B� � �"¨ � ��/\u>��� x � �Æu>��� x /\u>��� xçLïnè¬�Æu>��� x ��Å ��7 'nëcøÕë#��-,�cëíúkøHê*'nçbêmúbçLì&'�' �� ëcø ? $}ìkðLï*)nú1��ürý Ù çLø�ú � çLïnè»' � �K ��·�ò� �M� '��� �K nuË�.� x � � É úkïnìbú"/�'��@ëíøÕç��íø!ðÈçLï ? $�ìbðLï*)�ú1� îOænïÓìdê�ëíðLï �u Ù ç{ø!ú { ò�9LúkïÓúké!ç=�G$ x Ø ý 7 'núbðLé!ú�� { � { /Hê('núbé!úfú1��ëíø§ê�øÈçv-nçLé§êrëÂêrëcð{ï����.�¹Õ¢~¾�� � � �"�*�*�¢�CÎQ fðLî;� ø�ænì&'fê*'nçbêï$ � øl-nç{ïM�W� U�} Õ?~ � � � � �*�"�*���NÎi FçLïnèFê('nú���çbêré!ë�� � �xÒ�èÓúkûnïnúbè�ürý Á �ÕÔ<� ��� Ux} �Õ� U Ö Á �Ì� üYú"�íðLï,9{ø�ê�ð Å � ¦CúkûnïÓú 'fòÎó Ò õ ó ürý'F��@g���º� �"¨ � �Õ@ � �»@¬�@8� ó Ò � �<7 'Óúkï,/, ÌúS'Óç&)nú¤� ? $ ��� Ù �îOðLéS� '!� � ürý Ù çLø�ú � /�çLïnè'��*�� ���� � '!���*� ��ÌîOðLé»çLïrýz �� ó ô çLïnè »�+ó Ò Që ê(' l���5 n�©�.�t�s�~Ã� � �*�*�"���CÎ�� �É úbïnìkú�/�'���ç��íø!ðÈø!çbêrëcø�ûnúkø�� ? $ ��� Ù �l/�ë � ú � /"'���ëcø ? $}ìkðLï*)nú1� � ­

` Ý>Þ&Þ�æmÞ�æ = â â>Wa u Ù çLø�ú � òÄ� �ÿ�" Í� óÈôªÕ= n�©�Ã�8� �   x Ï ús��ç}ý çLø�ø!æ,��ú�ê('Óçbê � Þ ëíøF9Lë)�úbï�çLø u>��M�kÿ�  x � ú � Þ Ç çLïnè �^� ô � � ô � � � ���n���Ã���§ìbî � � { ����� �0/� { ��� { �0� � � ï�ê*'núÔîOð��#�íð& Qëíï,9�/< ÌúÔûné�ø§êÁìbðLïnø�ëcènúbé»ê('ÓúÔìkç{ø!úS S'Óúké!ú ú ëíø�ïÓðLïnø!ëíï,9Læc�cçLé0/çLïnè�ê('núbï�ê*'nú³9LúkïÓúké!ç=��ìkçLø�ú �u Ù ç{ø!ú � $ � ò»é�çLï,% ú � ÿØ� � x £ ëcïnìbú�çLél9·��ëcïñ � �t®C +çLïÓè ènð��åñ � �" ÿ�óÈôªÕ� n�T���8� �  �/! Ìú:'Óç&)nú�ènð��åñ � � óÈô�ürý �å¥ ��� ��çLïnè�ñ � �0/M�p� � �"¨ � ��/ � �Q/�îOðLé/¤� ènð��åñ � /| S'núbé!úX� ëíø�9Lë>)núkï�ü�ý

� � � ú �y� � ��� ú �Õ� � Ù ú��� Ù ú � � � ú �y� � � Ù ú � � � ú �y� � Ù ú

� «

Page 16: 東京工業大学shioura/papers/quadML.pdf! " # $&%(' )+*,' -.)0/.$ 1 $&2 3547698;:&)&= 8@? = 8A)&' ->$CB DFEHG;I>J>KLI>MONQPSRUT>VWV.XYVAZ []\!ZWV>G!^ I>MO_`V>\FPaRb_cNb\aRdN

çLïnè Ù ú � ó ô+� � ëcø&ê('Óú�)núkìdêrðLé\ Që ê('¼ç��#��ìkð���-YðLïnúkïrêrø�úkäaænç=�¢êrð¹ð{ïnú � Ï ú¶'Óç&)nú8� ��Åø!ëíïnìkú3� ú � � � ��Å Ç ürý 7 'núkðLé�ú"� { �#Å�� É úkïnìbú"/9ñ��@ëcø�Á,$�ìbðLï*)�ú+� �u Ù ç{ø!ú � $ � ò³9LúkïÓúké!ç=� úVx Ø ý 7 'núbðLé!ú�� { ��� «�/�ê*'núké�ú ú1��ëíø§êrø�ç�-nçLé ê�ë ê�ëíðLï~���.�ºÕ~5� � � � �"�*�*�¢� �   ðLîB� ø!ænì&' ê('nçbê7çLé09n��ëíï»ñ~� �" � óÈô~Õ\ n�©���t�Æ� � �~5�� � � �"�*�*�¢� � �� �çLïnè �g��� � � �ÕÔX����� �.�=���»� ��Ôå��~,�Cöp� � � � � �*�*�*�¢� �  ���îOðLé�ø!ð���ú� � � �ÈçUê�é!ë� �ýÞ � Ø ý �T¥ �Ð� �¼çLïnè���é!ð=-�ðLø�ëÂêrëcð{ï¹¥ � � /� Ìú 'nç�)�ú�ènð=�åñ����øl-nç{ï��W� Ux} ÕF~�� � � � �*�*�*�¢� �   � ¦Cúbûnïnú ñÁòÓó

ò õöóý(��+*1,¹ Èürý

ñ���´���� �� ´c� ´Í��´¬��óò �

ò� �M� ´+�8� � �l�

*1, �§ðbê*'núkéå Qëcø�ú*���

7 'núkïc/¶� ñC� �Cëíø³Á,$�ìkð{ï()nú1�+ürý Ù çLø�ú � $ ���F£ ëíïnìkúÈñ��*�ò� �M� @Z�F� Ux} �p� � ñC���"��@g�CîOðLéM@:�

ó Ò /�ñ���ëíøç=�cø�ð�Á,$�ìbðLï*)�ú+� �u Ù ç{ø!ú � ò·9Lúbïnúké�ç���� x Ø ý 7 'ÓúkðLé�ú"� { �Ð� w /�ê*'núké�úÔú+�0ëíø§êrø�ç�-nçLé ê�ë ê�ëíðLï»���.�»Õx~��� � � �"�*�*�¢� �  ¼ðLî.� ø�ænì&'¼ê*'nçbê�ñ��� ��·� ò� �M� ñN�|�� nu>��� x �X�� ²� ó ô �§ QëÂê*'7çÈîOç���ë2� ý ðLîäaænçLèné�çbê�ëíì ? $�ìbðLï*)�ú1� îOænïÓìdê�ëíðLïnø»ñN��òÓó U�} õ ó)(��+*1,¹ s9Lë)�úkï�ürý

ñN�c�� nu>��� x ��� �� nu>��� x � uË�.� x nuË�.� x �� nu>��� x � ó U } � ��� Ux} � � � ���

*1, �§ðbê*'núkéå Qëcø�ú*���

£ ëíïnìkú¹úkçLì&'��AñN�^� � ëcø¶Á,$�ìkð{ï()nú1� ürý Ù çLø!ú � $ � /�ñ � �Y/M�;�ò� �M� �§ñN�t� � �0/�uË�.� x ���Y/¬� óÈôQ�

ëcøÕç��íø!ð:Á,$�ìbðLï*)�ú1� � ­

Ú çþà\ßnß9ÝgßnÜrâ áïè·édá¢ÞYÛCí!ÜQáµê�ëìédá¢ÞYÛCí!ÜQá î9à9Û9á¢Ürâ ÞYÛ\Þ�Þcí�ÜaÝ ÜNhFÜ+ÚbÛ0Ü*Ü�ÿ!ÜaÝvènßÓÜ*éÜrâ á�Ü

� ï¼ê('Óëcø»ø!úkì¯ê�ëíðLï,/M �ú�ìkðLïnø�ëcèÓúkéÌèÓëcø�ìké!ú¯ê�ú�îOænïÓìdê�ëíðLïnø»ènúkûÓïnúkè�ð�)�úbé�ê*'nú�ëíïrê�ú"9{úkéA�íçbê�ê�ëíìkú×�ôêrðCëcïÓènëcìbçbê�ú@çCø�ænü~ê*�cú@ènë#@Yúké!úbïnìkúÕüYúdêU Ìúkúbïmê*'nú@ènëíø!ìké�údêrúìbçLø!ú@ç{ïnèÌê('nú@ìbðLïrê�ëíïaænðLænøìkçLø�ú ��7 é!çLïnø�ëÂêrëcð{ïQê�ð@ê('ÓúèÓëcø�ìké!ú¯ê�ú»ìkçLø�ú»ëíø�äSæÓëÂêrú»ø0�ÈðSðbê*'¼îOðLé�Á,$�ìbðLï*)�ú+�0ë ê]ý�� 7 'núbðLé!ú��« ��� �ùünæ~ê�ê*'nçbêîOðLé ? $�ìbðLï*)�ú1��ë ê]ý�ëcø�ø�ð���údê('Óëcï,9Qænïnú+��-�úbìdê�úbè � ø!úkú 7 'núbðLé!ú���ø·« � � /c« � { /çLïnèë � ¥�� �� s�¶ 25476&û"ü�8:9<;<¸l2.Ç�476&û"ü�8:9<;-º�ôiüx6(ùKú1û"üMó

½ÎðLéÌçþø ý��:��ú¯ê�é!ëíì���çbê�é�ë>���ÿ�L� ô /� �ú�èÓúkûnïnú�çÔäSæÓçLèné!çUê�ëíì�îOænïnìdêrëcð{ïS'�òC×�ôÁõ óürýS'.�0/M��� � �"¨ � ��/ � �Q/ª�0/3�v×�ôQ� � Ï ú�ìbç��2�0ø!ænì&'fç�îOænïnì¯ê�ëíðLï�25476&û"ü�8:9<;Qëíî�ëÂêCø!çbêrëcø�ûnúkø

� w

Page 17: 東京工業大学shioura/papers/quadML.pdf! " # $&%(' )+*,' -.)0/.$ 1 $&2 3547698;:&)&= 8@? = 8A)&' ->$CB DFEHG;I>J>KLI>MONQPSRUT>VWV.XYVAZ []\!ZWV>G!^ I>MO_`V>\FPaRb_cNb\aRdN

ê('nú³-né�ð�-Yúké§êrëcúbø��åÁ�½ � u × x �@çLïnè��TÁ�½ � u × x �!ò= è·îQÙ�d × km> '.�0/M�A*L'.��@g� � '§�Y/S±�@g�A*#'.�0/X°B@^� ����/M�C@8� ènð=���Ä'!�l/= è·î�Ú�d × km> DFE � ó ø�ænì&'»ê*'nçbêx'.�0/�*�I Ù ���K'.�0/M�7*�I E ����/3� ènð=���Ä'��¢I¤�v×��0/

S'núké�ú�ènð=���Ä'��~�N/��ª× ô Õ7'.�0/,��PÛ*1,¹ +¬C'�ëíøzìbç��2�íúkè-2 Ç 476&û"ü�8:9<;�ëcî.ê('nú�îOænïnì¯ê�ëíðLï 'Ôò× U õ ó¬/Q S'Óúké!ú ����� �  e(¤�Ã/0ènúbûnïnúbèfürý 'F�0/W�(�X/M���K'.�0/p��/W� Ù �B�0�0/W�g�X/M���v× U¶�ëcønÁ,$�ìkð{ï()nú1� � Ï úÌènúbïnðbêrú�ürý ÅBu × x �§é�úkø0- � / Å Ç u × x �9ê('nú»ø!údêCðLîµ��çbê�é�ëcìbúkø�� �B� ô ø!ænì&'ê('nçUê�ê('núCîOæÓïnìdêrëcðLï['�ð�)�úké;×�ôÔëíø�ÁM$}ìkðLï*)nú1�ï� é!úkø0- � /<Á§ÇË$}ìkðLï*)�ú+��� � Á,$&Ê�Á.ÇË$�ìbðLï*)�ú+�0ë ê]ý ðLîäaænçLèné�çbê�ëíìÔîOænïÓìdê�ëíðLïnø�ð&)núké³×�ô�ìkçLï¬üYúÈì&'nçLé!ç{ìdê�úbé!ë#�kúbè+ürý�ê('ÓúÔø!ç=�Èú�-né!ð=-�úbé§ê�ëíúkø¹çLøê('nð{ø!úþð�)�úbé¹ó ô /�ë � ú � / ÅAu × x � Å çLïÓè Å Ç u × x � Å Ç � ��é�ð(ðLîOøQçLé�úÔäaænë ê�úþø�ë2��ë#�cçLé�çLïnèê('núbé!úbîOðLé!úmð���ë ê!ê�úbè �gih\ÜaÞYÝgÜQâ Ú�a§Ù 2�9(ù�� �3� ô sGËl�l9lü�t

�§ë#�8� � ÅBu × x íàî � { � � �<t � ëcë#�8�ì� Å Ç u × x íàî � { � { �£s

� su× �3476&û"ü�8:9<;<¸l� Çó476&û"ü�8:9<;»º!ô|üx6(ùKú1û"üMó

½ÎðLé�ç�ø§ý�����údêré!ëíì���çbêré!ë� �Û� ô /� �úFènúbûnïnúFç�äSæÓçLèné!çUê�ëíìÁîOænïnìdêrëcð{ï²ñ©ò;×�ô õóR(z�+*1,¹ Èürý

ñ��� ���� �� � 5�K �v×�ô|�� n�©�Ã�·� � ���*1, � ðbê('núbéT Qëíø!ú*�l� �å« ��� �

Ï úmìbç��2��ø�ænì&'7ç�îOænïÓìdê�ëíðLï3�B476&û"ü�8:9<;Qëíîzë ê¹ø!çbêrëcø�ûnúkø�ê('nú³-né�ð�-Yúké§ê]ý�� ? $ ��� Ù u × x �!ò= ëìé1à��%��d × k> �M \�0´Æ� ènð����ñC/c�M�;� ø!æc-,- Ó �� 3��´��l/ D ��� ø!æ,-,-l�.�� 3��´C��ò

ñ��K ��A*åñ��K´C� � ñ��� ¤��� � *K� � �A* ñ���´i*�� � ��� � �l�Ï ú�ènúkïnðUê�ú�ürý Þ u × x ê('nú�ø�údêÈðLî���çbêré!ëíìkúkø ��� ô ø�ænì&'þê('nçUê�ê('nú�îOæÓïnìdêrëcðLïÍ�å« ��� �ð�)�úké·�" z�ª×�ôÃÕ¢ n�T���·� �  Cëíø ? $�ìbðLï*)�ú1� � ? çbêré!ëíìkúbø�ëcï Þ u × x ìbçLï�ü�ú@ì&'ÓçLé!çLì¯ê�úbé!ë#�kúkèçLøÕîOð��#�cð� Qø!ògih\ÜaÞYÝgÜQâ Ú�aKÚ�n �Ã÷�ùKø¢ú�; �B� ô õy9£wKû"ü�½(ó�ùTû Þ u × x úuz�÷"üx{3û"üxw |�úuz

�g��� * � �ÕÔ � ��ëcï,� �^� ��* �g� Ôå� �g� Ô:* �g� �^ ���M�&�1�^�C~,�Cöµ����¿�ú1ùY�¬�"�&�0�|  ý �W~,�Cöå S��þ���� �å« � � �

` Ý>Þ&Þ�æca ã îOænïÓìdê�ëíðLïFñz9{ë>)núkïFürýØ�å« �Ð� ��ëíø ? $�ìbðLï*)�ú+��ëcî·� ? $ ��� Ù u × x ��'nð��íènø�îOðLéÐçLïrý \�0´¬� èÓð����»ñ� QëÂê*' ô� �M� Õ l���z´+�MÕt��¥¬� ìkî � u � ¿=/ 7 ' � { �Ð� x �0/Q S'nëíì&'FìkçLïÁüYú�ø�ë2��-,� ý

� ¿

Page 18: 東京工業大学shioura/papers/quadML.pdf! " # $&%(' )+*,' -.)0/.$ 1 $&2 3547698;:&)&= 8@? = 8A)&' ->$CB DFEHG;I>J>KLI>MONQPSRUT>VWV.XYVAZ []\!ZWV>G!^ I>MO_`V>\FPaRb_cNb\aRdN

é!ú+ Qé!ë ê!ê�úbï7çLøX�å« � � � � ­ã äSæÓçLèné!çUê�ëíìQîOæÓïnìdêrëcðLï�ñÁòc×�ô�õ ó 9{ë>)núkïfü�ý

ñ��� ���� �� � �� ��v× ô � �å« � { �

ëcø�ìkç��#�cúbè ? Ç�476&û"ü�8:9<;Ìëcînê('Óú�îOænïnì¯ê�ëíðLï ñÁòc× U õ ó (¤�+*1,¹ �/� S'núké�ú � ��� �  á(Æ�Ã/ènúkûÓïnúkè�ü�ý

ñ��� ��g�1 ���� ñ��� ����� ��¶�~�� n�©�Ã�l���*1, �§ðUê('núbéT Qëíø!ú*�l� �0�� ��g�0 ��·�v× U �

ëcø ? $}ìkðLï*)nú1� � Ï ú�ènúbïnðbêrúÈürý Þ Ç u × x ê*'nú�ø!ú¯êÔð{î·��çbêré!ëíìkúbø � � ô ø�ænì&'Áê('nçbêCê*'núîOænïnì¯ê�ëíðLïØ�T« � { �ð�)�úbép×�ôFëcø ? ÇË$�ìkð{ï()nú1� �§7 'núbðLé!ú��­« � � 9Lë>)núkøÐê*'nú�îOð��#�íð& Qëíï,9þì&'ÓçLé!çLì+$ê�úbé!ë#�kçbêrëcðLïfðLî9äaænçLèné�çbê�ëíì ? ÇÌ$}ìkðLï*)nú1� îOænïnì¯ê�ëíðLïnø �gih\ÜaÞYÝgÜQâ Ú�aYj�n �Ã÷�ù�ø_ú�; �B� ô õy9£wKû"ü�½(óBù©û Þ Ç u × x úuz8÷"üx{sû"üxw |�úuzA�å« � � �<t �g����������M���0�����Ã�<t¶÷"üx{ �g����� ��ëíï�� �^� �t� �g� �t ²�K�M�&�0�^�C~:��� ¿�ú1ùY��~ ¨���"�&�1�c ��.�!ûWwY{Wsgih\ÜaÞYÝgÜQâ Ú�aY® Þ u × x � Þ ÷"üx{ Þ Ç u × x � Þ Ç s` Ý>Þ&Þ�æca Ï úøl'nð� ©ê('Óú»îOðLé0��úké�ðLï,� ý � � ? $ �¢� Ù u × x ��îOðLé�ñfðLî��å« �Ð� �ÐìbçLïÔüYúÌé�ú1 Qé!ë ê!êrúkïçLø

��ëíï�<�cã¹äÕåÕåOæ � ç � �" �� �g� �� �� �g� * �g��� * �g��� � � �g���   ����K�M ²�v× ô Që ê('� n�©�Ã��� � ���M�n� ø!æ,-c- Ó �� ��0���

S'nëíì&',/Sêrð�9Lúdê*'núké� QëÂê*' 7 'núkð{é!ú"�Ö« � � /Îë2��-,�íëíúkø���ëcï �Õ�yãóäÕåÕåoæ �èç � �" � �g� �à � �^�   ��� îOðLéçLïrý3 ��v× ô Që ê('� n�©�Ã��� � çLïnèÔçLïrý��n� ø�æ,-,- Ó �K �� � É úkïÓìkú"/§� ? $ ��� Ù ð �;'nð��íènøÐîOðLé /�ë � ú � / � Þ ürý 7 'núkð{é!ú"� { �Ð� ¥z� ëcë#� � ­7 'nú�ëíïnì"�íænø�ëcðLïÓø@ëcï 7 'ÓúkðLé�ú"� « � ¥¹çLé!úp-né!ð�-YúkéZ¬�îOð{é�ú1��ç���-,�íú"/Sê('nú»ø§ý����Èú¯ê�é�ëcìB��çbêré!ë� �B� �X9{ë>)núkï7ürý

�« � ¥� « {¥ {:w

� S'Óúké!ú � � � �¿{ � � �� � � �� � � � {

ü�ú��cð{ï,9Løùê�ð Þ Ç çLïÓè�ïnðUê@ê�ð Þ Ç u × x �

� y

Page 19: 東京工業大学shioura/papers/quadML.pdf! " # $&%(' )+*,' -.)0/.$ 1 $&2 3547698;:&)&= 8@? = 8A)&' ->$CB DFEHG;I>J>KLI>MONQPSRUT>VWV.XYVAZ []\!ZWV>G!^ I>MO_`V>\FPaRb_cNb\aRdN

Ü ` Ý>Þ&Þ�æÐÞ

! s�¶ "�ø�û(ûXz1óez"û"ø%·;ôµ÷W{"ø�÷�ùKúX6�2x476&û"ü�8:9<;<¸l2 Ç 476&û"ü�8:9<;»º!ôiüx6(ù�ú1û"üMó

` Ý>Þ&Þ�æCÞ�æMgih\ÜaÞÎÝ^ÜQâ j�a�Ú�a 7 'nú�4¯ëíî 6 -nçLé§ê�ëcøÌë2����úkènëíçbêrú�îOé!ð�� 7 'núbðLé!ú�� { �����.7 ð-né!ð�)núfê('Óúì4¯ð{ï,�Âý ëcî 6 -ÓçLé§ê*/CçLø!ø�æ,��ú�� � Å �B7 'núbï,/X� ø�çbê�ëíø!ûnúbøÈê*'nú ìbðLïnènë ê�ëíðLï� { � � �Õürý 7 'núbðLé!ú�� { �Ð���C£ ëcïÓìkú�ç{él9���ëcïÄ'�ëíøçLï�Á,$}ìkðLï*)�ú+�v�cëíïnúbçLé»ø�ænünø0-nçLìkú¤�§ìbî � u � � /7 ' � ¥ � { ¥ x �0/ùê('núbé!ú�ú+�0ëíø§êrøþç�-ÓçLé§êrëÂêrëcðLï¾�����5Õ�~5� � � � �*�"�*��� �  ¬ðLîB� ø�ænì&' ê('ÓçbêçLél9���ëíï¢'ï� ø0-nçLï��W� Ux} Õb~»� � � � �*�*�*��� �  �ürý���é!ð�-YðLø�ëÂêrëcðLï � �����n£ ëcïÓìkúÆ%{úbé!�Ô�çLél9���ëíï¢'!/! Ìús'nç�)�ú Á � � � U�} � �Õ� U�} Á ��� � � îOð{é�ç��#�C�8�Î�öçLïÓè#~Ã� � � � �*�"�*��� � / S'núké�ú Á � ëíø�ê('Óú8�©$;ê*'�ìkð��íæ,��ï�ðLî·� �§7 'nëíøB-né�ð�-�úbé§ê]ý�/�ê�ð�9{údê('Óúké; Që ê('ï� { � � �0/Hë#�:-c�cëíúkøê('nçUê�� ëíømçFü,�cðSì&%*$�ènëíç�9Lð{ïnç��§��çbêré!ë� ø!ænì&'Fê('nçUêÈúkçLì&' ü,�íð(ì&% �¤uË�.� x üYú"�íðLï,9Lø�êrðBÅ �� ê øl'nð{æ,�cè­üYú�ïnðbê�úbè ê*'nçbê é�çLï,%��¤uË�.� x � ÕË���,Õc� � îOð��#�cð� QøFîOé!ð�� ê('Óú úbäaænçbê�ëíðLï%{úbé��¤uË�.� x �´� U } � ­

` Ý>Þ&Þ�æFÞ�æÍgih\ÜSÞÎÝgÜQâ jba�j�a Ï ú7ûné�ø§ê²-né�ð�)�úÔê('Óú54¯ðLïc�Âý ëcî 6 -ÓçLé§ê �A£ æ,-c-�ðLø�ú¼ê('Óçbê' ëíø¬ÁM$}ìkðLï*)nú1� �X7 'Óúkï,/mènð��L' � $ ëcøfçLïÎÁ,$�ìbðLï*)�ú1� �íëcïÓúkçLéFø!æÓünøl-nç{ìkú ç{ïnè©ìkçLïü�úfé!ú�-né!úbø!úbï�êrúkè çLøà$ � ø0-nçLï��W� Ux} Õá~¾� � �*�*�*�¢�CÎQ  ürý5ø!ð���úÃ-nçLé ê�ë ê�ëíðLï¾���.�ÎÕ~ � � �*�*�*���CÎQ  ðLîB� � ¦CúkûÓïnú ' òÌó Ò õ ó ürý '.��@g�¬� � �"¨ � �Õ@ � �»@Í��@Ø� ó Ò �0/ S'núké�ú Á �ÕÔ<� ��� Ux} �Õ� U Ö Á �Ì� ��7 'núbï,/� ÌúS'nç�)�ú.'.� Ò� �M� @Z�F� Ux} �n� 'F��@g���K�x@X� ó Ò �0/ë2��-,� ý�ëcïc9ÍÁ,$}ìkðLï*)�ú+��ëÂê]ý ð{î '�/Ìë � ú � / � � Å �p7 'Óú�4¯ëcî 6 -nç{é§ê�ëíøþðLü*)�ëíðLænøÁîOé!ð=� ê*'núènëíø!ìkæÓø!ø!ëíðLï�ç{ü�ð�)�úmçLïÓè#��é!ð=-�ðLø�ëÂêrëcð{ï � ����� ­

! su× "�ø�û(ûXz1óez"û"ø%·;ôµ÷W{"ø�÷�ùKúX6��B476&û"ü�8:9<;<¸l��Çó476&û"ü�8:9<;»º�ôiüx6(ùKú1û"üMó

! su×ls�¶ "�ø�û(ûXz�ûXz$"�ø"û1öCû"ó&ú1ùKú1û"ü µ s&%� êÈìkçLï�üYú�úkçLø�ë2� ý ø0'nð� QïFê*'nçbê �_Þ Ç¶�§é�úkøl- � / � Þ Ç �Cë#��-,�cëíúkø�� ? ÇÌ$ ��� Ù Óð $yñ¶��§é�úkøl- � /�� ? ÇÈ$ ��� Ù ð �l�:� ø!úbúÌê('nús-né�ð(ð{îOø�ðLî 7 'núkð{é!ú"��ø { � y çLïnè { ��� � üYú"�íð� S� � É úkïnìbú"/ëÂê¹ø�æ,Ä�ìkúkø�ê�ð�-né�ð�)�ú@ê('númîOð��#�cð� Qëíï,9 �` Ý>Þ�ã�Þ�Þrâ Ürâ ÞÎÛ�Üba Ù�§ë#� n ü�|%�Ã÷�ù�ø_ú�; �B� ô ó^÷�ùKú¯óÐzX|tú¯ü�½Ã� ? ÇÌ$ ��� Ù Óð $yñ¶�pú¯ónöCû"ó&ú1ùKú�8:9»{W9Ó\üMú1ù9£s�§ëíë2� n ü�|à�Ã÷�ùKø_ú�; �B� ô ó^÷�ùKú¯óÐzX|^ú¯ü�½¬� ? ÇÈ$ ��� Ù ð �pú¯ónöCû"ó&ú1ùKú�8:9Aóo9<�súX{W9Ó\üMú1ù�9£s` Ý>Þ&Þ�æca Ï ú -né�ð�)�úï�§ë#�ÁðLï,� ý ø�ëcïnìbú¾� ëcë#�þìbçLï©ü�ú�ø0'nð� Qï5ø�ë2��ë#�cçLé0�Âý � Á�údê#I üYú�çLïúkë#9Lúkï*)(ç��íænú�ðLî /zçLïnè¤ +üYú»ê('nú�ìbðLé!é�úkø0-�ðLïÓènëcïc9Áúkë#9Lúkï*)�úbìdêrðLé� QëÂê*' ø�æ,-,- Ó �K ��s�� þ �Á�údê��·�ï��';��ëcïnë#��ë2�bú�ê('nún)(ç��íænú�IQ � ç=�Èð{ï,98�n� ø!æ,-c- Ó �� �� � � ? ÇÌ$ �¢� Ù Óð $yñ¶��ë#�:-c�cëíúkø

IQ �)( �� � �g�*(¶Ñ ��ëcï¶� � ����ëcï�<� Ueé � �*(c� � �g�  S���Èëíï¶� � ����ëcï�<� Ueé � �*(y� I� �  �� � w ��� �

��Å

Page 20: 東京工業大学shioura/papers/quadML.pdf! " # $&%(' )+*,' -.)0/.$ 1 $&2 3547698;:&)&= 8@? = 8A)&' ->$CB DFEHG;I>J>KLI>MONQPSRUT>VWV.XYVAZ []\!ZWV>G!^ I>MO_`V>\FPaRb_cNb\aRdN

Ø ý�ê('ÓúÈì&'ÓðLëcìbúÔðLî��+'l/C Ìú:'nç�)�úSI� �*(:� IQ � îOð{éQç{ï�ý��²�5ø�æ,-,- Ó �K �� � É úbïnìkú�/A� w ��� �ë2��-,�íëíúkø-IQ �*(sѺ� ðLéHIQ �)(�Ñ I� � îOðLé�ø�ð���úS���©ø!æ,-,- � �� ��l/�úbçLì&' ðLî� S'Óëcì&'Fý0ëíú"�íènøI Ñ � � É úkïnìbú"/ ëíø¶-YðLø�ëÂêrë>)nú¹ènúbûnïnë ê�ú � ­

! su×lsu× "�ø�û(ûXz1ó�ûXz�Ël�l9&û"ør9<�só µ s&,¤÷"üx{ µ s�¶ � q�úuvÏ úCûÓé!ø§êX-né�ð�)�ú�ê('númúbäSæÓë>)(ç��íúkïnìbú²4¢� ? ÇÈ$ ��� Ù �@çLïnèfé!ç{ï,% � ÿ&íïî � ? ÇÈ$ ��� Ù Ó �íïî � ? ÇÌ$ ��� Ù Óð ��íïî � ? ÇË$ ��� Ù Óð $yñ¶��íàî �TÁ.ÇË$ � ¡�É � �#6ènÜQâªâ�ß�Ü�a�Ú = î�ßnÝüû|ß,Þ.-FäåÜQâ�âªß"> 2�9(ù õy9s÷"ü � �fÿ¾øN9&÷Ww:�Ã÷�ù�ø_ú�;Ã÷"üx{ Á � ó ò sËl�l9lü�t �� Á z"û"øXó^ûN�39Bü\û"üMüx9нi÷�ùKú�8:9; �� óÈôzúuzs÷"üx{¬û"üxw |¤úuz;´ � Á � � z"û"øS9<8:9løc|´¬� ó ò ¿�ú1ùY��´ � � ® � sènÜQâªâ�ß�Ü�a�j � ? Ç $ �¢� Ù Óð $Õñp��íàî �åÁ Ç $ � ¡·É �£s` Ý>Þ&Þ�æca Ï ú�ûné�ø§ê�ïÓðbê�ú»ê*'nçbê¬� ? ÇÈ$ ��� Ù Óð $Õñp�»ë2��-,�íëcúbø�ê('nú¹ïnðLïnø�ëcïc9Læ,�íçLé!ë ê]ý ðLî ürý��é!ð�-YðLø!ë ê�ëíðLï w ����� ¦CúkïnðUê�ëíï,9 � � ürý:�ì�º� Á �Ì� �0/" �ú�'nç�)�ú �ì����/¢ë � ú � / ô���M� Á ���©�^� �� � �K�n�����0/c S'nëcì&'�ìkçLïfüYúQé�ú1 Qé�ëÂê�ê�úkïfçLø

ô���M� Á ��� �g� * ��Ò��� �T� Á �©� �(� �g� � �^� ���´� � �K�n�����l�

7 'nú7ìbðLïnènë ê�ëíðLï�� { � { ��îOðLé:� ëíø¼úbäaænë>)(ç��íúkïrêþêrð ç=�2�ùê('Óú�ìbð(ú�ÄÈìbëcúbïrê�øþëíï ê*'nëcø:�íëcïnúbçLéìkð��¹ünëíïnçbê�ëíðLïÁüYúkëíï,9�ïnð{ïnïnú"9{çbê�ë)�ú�/| S'núké�úkçLøHê*'núA�íçbê�ê�úkéÐìkðLïÓènëÂêrëcð{ïÁëcø�úbäaænë>)(ç��íúkïrê*/&ürýÁ�ú"����ç w � � /kê�ð�´ � �g�\Ñ �Èëíï¶� � �"��ëíï ��Ò��� ´ � �g�  »îOðLé�çLïrý³´Æ��óÈôn QëÂê*'p´ � � � ��´ �<Ñ�� / S'nëíì&'7ëíøïÓðbê('nëíï,9Èünæ~ê¤� ? Ç $ �¢� Ù Óð $yñ¶� � ­7 ðÁø0'nð� ê*'nú�úkäaænë)(ç��íúkïnìbú»4¢� ? Ç $ ��� Ù Óð �Ríïî � ? Ç $ ��� Ù Óð $yñ¶�l/ 6 Ìú�ænø!úÌê*'nú�îOð��$�cð� Qëíï,9:-né!ð�-Yúké ê]ý�òènÜQâªâ�ß�Ü�a�® �z ��� ô ó^÷�ùKú¯óÐÓe9ló��TÁ.ÇË$ � ¡�É �<t¶ùY�l9lüÍ÷"ü�|Bö!ø¢ú¯üx6lúÌöC÷WwQó&ôµõ<�Ã÷�ùKø_ú�;ÃûXz ó^÷�ù�ú¯óÐÓe9lós�TÁ.ÇÌ$ � ¡·É �£s` Ý>Þ&Þ�æca ��æ~ê�� � � � �<7 'núbï,/\�÷ø�çbê�ëíø!ûÓúkøs� { � { � � �zçLé§êrëÂêrëcð{ï çLïÓèz�÷çLø

� �U� � ñ ñ � ñUñ

� �ì� � �U� � � ñ�;ñ � �nñUñ

QëÂê*' ø�ænü,��çbêré!ëíìkúkø �U� �*� �U� � � ô+� � / � � ñ � ñ � � � � ô � � � ô ñ(�*�*�"�"� � ô ¯ ôF� � �l/§� � � ñ ��;ñ � �Ô� Á ô � � Á ô ñg�"�*�*�¢� Á ô ¯ ô+� � �l/ ñUñ¤� � ôbô /·�;ñUñ�� Á ôbô � Ï ú³ Që#�2��øl'Óð& ê*'nçbê �U� ëíøïnðLïnø�ëcïc9Læ,�íçLéÕçLïnè�� �U� � � � ø�çbê�ëíø!ûÓúkø�� { � { � �Ï ú:'nç�)�ú Á ôkô Ñÿ� ø!ëíïnìkú�� ëíøQç�ïnð{ïnø!ëíï,9Læ,�íçLéS��çbê�é�ë>� Që ê('¾� { � { � ��7 'núbé!úbîOðLé!ú�/�ê*'nú

� �

Page 21: 東京工業大学shioura/papers/quadML.pdf! " # $&%(' )+*,' -.)0/.$ 1 $&2 3547698;:&)&= 8@? = 8A)&' ->$CB DFEHG;I>J>KLI>MONQPSRUT>VWV.XYVAZ []\!ZWV>G!^ I>MO_`V>\FPaRb_cNb\aRdN

ëcï*)núké!ø�ú�ðLî �U� ëíøA9Lë)�úbï�ürý � � � �U� � � �"¨ Á ôbô �l� � ñg�;ñ � /M S'nëíì&'�øl'nð� QøÐê*'nçbê �U� ëíøïnðLïnø�ëcïc9Læ,�íçLé � ½ÎðLé�çLïrý³�&�1�s��� c�kÿ§ � Që ê('��8����i/" �ú·'nç�)�ú Á ��� � Á ��� � Á � ô Á ô � ¨ Á ôkô ���ø!ëíïnìkú Á ��� � Á � ô � Á ô ���~� çLïnè Á ôbô Ñ�� � ½Yð{é@çLïrýÆ�n����p�kÿ§ �/c �ú³'nç�)�úô+� ����M� Á ��� �

ôF� ��l�M� Á ��� ��� Á � ô ¨ Á ôbô �

ôF� ��l�M� Á ô ��� � Á � ô ��� Á � ô ¨ Á ôbô �

ôF� ��l�M� Á ô ���~� �

É úbïnìkú�/ �ì� � �U� �Õ� � ø�çbê�ëíø!ûnúbø�� { � { � � ­ènÜQâªâ�ß�Ü�a�Ú � ? ÇÌ$ �¢� Ù Óð �Kíïî � ? ÇÌ$ ��� Ù Óð $yñ¶�£s` Ý>Þ&Þ�æca � ê�ø�æ,Ä�ìkúbøQê�ð øl'Óð& ê*'nú¹4Xí�� 6 ènëcé�úkì¯ê�ëíðLï � ãÌø�ø!æ,��úØ� ? ÇÌ$ ��� Ù Óð $yñ¶��îOðLé � ½Yð{é; Ø� óÈô�ë ê�ø�æ,Ä�ìkúkø�êrðÁìkðLïnø�ëcèÓúké��8�åø�æ,-,- Ó �K ��n QëÂê*'²�Èëíïnë#��æ,�ÿ � �g� � ��æ~êð��~�"�:�»� Õ" � �� �  �/ �Ö� �^� Õ"���Øð���� u>ð x /�çLïnè �¾ nu>ð x ��7 'núbï,/, �úS'nç�)�ú�¶�+ø�æ,-,- Ó � \��� ø�æ,-,- Ó �K ��l/9ø!æ,-c-l�§� ����,ø!æ,-c-l�§�� ��0/zçLïÓè � �g� �Î � �g� ���M�3��ð�� �Ø ý²Á�ú"����çLø w � { ç{ïnè w � ¥�/i �úS'nç�)�ú�� ? Ç $ �¢� Ù Óð $Õñp�@îOð{é /�ë#�:-c�Âý�ëíï,9

� �^��Ñ �Èëíï¶� � � ��ëíï�<� � é � � ( � � �g�  �� � w � � �

Ø ýFê('nú¹ì&'nðLëíìkú�ð{îC��/, Ìú�'nç�)�ú � �g�§� � �^� îOðLé��3�+ø�æ,-,- Ó � F� � É úkïÓìkú"/zîOé!ð�� � w � � �îOð��#�cð� Qø � �^��Ñ �Èëíïp� � �"��ëíï �Õ�yãóäÕåÕåüæ � ç � � �^�   � ­ènÜQâªâ�ß�Ü�a�Ü � ? Ç $ �¢� Ù Ó �Kíïî � ? Ç $ ��� Ù Óð �£s` Ý>Þ&Þ�æca £ ëíïnìbú

ñ��� 3�!�� � ��� � �0�A*åñ��K´»*

!��� � ��� � �0���åñ��K ���� ñ���´��

�!�K ¤��´�� � � �g� � �g� �A*

!ñ � �^�Ì� * �g��� � � �^�Ì� �l�

� ? ÇÈ$ ��� Ù Ó �@îOðLéÕñ�ìbçLï�üYúmé!ú+ Qé!ë ê!ê�úbï7çLøÕîOð��#�íð& Qø�ò�M �� óÈôi���M�;� ø!æ,-,- Ó �K ���� D ��� ø�æ,-,-l�§�K ��x(z� �  mò

u � �g� PÍ � �g� x ðLéSu � �g� �� � �g� çLïnè �^�Ì� * �g��� � � �g��� P � x �� w � { �

S'núké�ú � �:�Ö®+çLïnè �g� �:� � � � � � �K�X�����Qürý+ìkðLï*)�úbïrê�ëíðLï � � ïv-nçLé ê�ëíìkæ,�íçLé0/A� w � { �îOðLé� ¾��� � � ���ÁçLïnèà ¾�����8�V� � ë#��-,�cëíúkø �^�Ì� * � �Õ�A� � �g� � ��� îOð{éQç=�2�<�X���çLïnè�~ª����(v� �   � É úkïnìbúQê('Óú¼ø�úkìkð{ïnè¬ìkç{ø!úÈëcï¾� w � { �mëcøQë#�:-YðLø�ø!ëíü,�cú�/Ðç{ïnè¹� w � { �Qëíøúkäaænë)(ç��cúbïrê»êrð�� ? ÇÌ$ ��� Ù Óð � � ­ènÜQâªâ�ß�Ü�a�ß � ? ÇÌ$ �¢� Ù �s÷"üx{¹é!çLïc% �²ÿ íïî � ? ÇÌ$ �¢� Ù Ó �Cs` Ý>Þ&Þ�æca ãÌø�ø!æ,��úv� ? ÇÌ$ ��� Ù Ó ��îOðLé�ñ �n7 'Óúkï,/� �úÁìbçLï¬øl'Óð& ê('ÓçbêÁé�çLï,% � ÿ ëcïê('núø!ç=�Èú� Ìç�ýfç{ø/��é!ð=-�ðLø�ëÂêrëcð{ï w ��� �§ë#�l/� S'nëíì&'3-né�ð&)núkø�ê('núÆ4Xí�� 6 ènëíé!úkì¯ê�ëíðLï �10 ïmê*'nú

� �

Page 22: 東京工業大学shioura/papers/quadML.pdf! " # $&%(' )+*,' -.)0/.$ 1 $&2 3547698;:&)&= 8@? = 8A)&' ->$CB DFEHG;I>J>KLI>MONQPSRUT>VWV.XYVAZ []\!ZWV>G!^ I>MO_`V>\FPaRb_cNb\aRdN

ðbê('ÓúkéB'nçLïÓè,/�� ? Ç $ �¢� Ù �mîOðLé�ñ�ý�ëíú"�íènø�ê('nú�-YðLø!ë ê�ë)�ú�ø�ú"��ëcèÓúkûnïnë ê�úbïnúkø�ø�ðLî /! S'nëcì&'ìkçLï�üYú@øl'nð� QïÈø!ë#��ë2�íçLél� ý�êrð2��é�ð�-YðLø!ë ê�ëíðLï w ��� �§ëíë2� �,7 'nëíøl/{ê�ð=9Lúdê*'núkéC Që ê('�é!ç{ï,% �²ÿ./ë2��-,�íëíúkø�ê('númø§êré!ëíìdê¹ìkð{ï()nú1��ë ê]ý¬îOðLéÕñ � É úbïnìkú�/;� ? ÇÈ$ ��� Ù Ó �ÕîOð��2�íð� Qø � ­7 'nú�úbäaænë>)(ç��íúkïÓìkúv4 ��Þ íàî � ? $ ��� Ù Ó �§íïî � ? $ ��� Ù Óð � 6 ìkçLï�ü�úmøl'Óð& Qïëcï�ê('ÓúQø�ë2��ë#�cç{é� Ìç}ý çLø�Á�ú"����çLø w � w çLïnè w � ¿�/&ë#��-,� ý0ëíï,9 7 'núkðLé�ú"� { ��� ¥��§ë#� �¦CúkûnïÓú � � �g��� �¶��� ô Ó � ürýÎ� { ��� � � � Ø ý¹� { ��� { �»çLïnè 7 'núbðLé!ú�� { ��� ¥²� ë2�0/! Ìú�'nç�)�úê('nú¹úkäaænë)(ç��cúbïnìkú�4 � Þ Ç�íàî �LÞ íàî � ? $ �¢� Ù Óð �îOðLé 6 /M S'núbé!úê*'nú�cç{ø§ê¹ìkðLïÓènëÂêrëcð{ï�ìbçLï�üYúmé!ú+ Qé!ë ê!ê�úbï�ëíï�ê�úké0��ø»ðLî çLø

= ë Ç é ` ó43\Óâ >

�§ë#�ª �� �g��Ñ ��ëíïp� � � ��ëcï�Õ�yãóäÕå<åOæ �èç � �� �g�  �K�M ²� óÈô³ QëÂê*': n�T��� Ñ�� ���M�n� ø!æc-,- Ó �� ��0����§ëíë2�� �� �g��Ñ ��ëíï�<�cã¹äÕåÕåOæ � ç � �� �g��K�M ²� óÈô³ QëÂê*': n�T��� �~� ���M�;� ø!æ,-,- Ó �� ��l�l�� ëcëíë#� �SÑ ��ëíï�<�cã¹äÕåÕåOæ �èç � � �^� ���M � ó ô QëÂê*': n�T���¢P � �l�

7 ð¼ìkðLïÓì"�íænènú»ê*'nú�-né�ð(ð{îHðLî 7 'ÓúkðLé�ú"� { � y /M Ìú�ø0'nð� ê('nú¹úkäaænë)Óç=�cúbïnìkúª4¢� ? ÇÈ$���ñ65iÓð �íïî � ? ÇÌ$ ��� Ù Óð � �#6ènÜQâªâ�ß�Ü�a�ì �z �3� ô ó^÷�ùKú¯óÐÓe9ló��TÁ.ÇË$ � ¡�É ��÷"üx{·úuz� n�©���áP � t\ù0�l9lü �XÑ ��ëíï �Õ� U � �g� s` Ý>Þ&Þ�æca ��æ~ê��ì� � � �C7 'núkï� �úS'nç�)�ú

��Ñ n�©�Ã�n�Í � Ù �� � � Ù � ô���M� �K � �g� �*�

ô� �M� Á ��� �l�

S'núké�úkçLø ô�¯�M� Á ���s� � îOðLé�ú1)núké ý���� � ü�ý � { � { � � É úbïnìkú: � �^� P � îOðLé�ø!ð���ú����� � ­ènÜQâªâ�ß�Ü�a�ò �z �3� ô ó^÷�ùKú¯óÐÓe9ló�� ? Ç $ ��� Ù ð �Zt�ùY�l9lü �^�Ì�\�~�g������� ���M�&�1�s�»���Cs` Ý>Þ&Þ�æca ½Yð{é»ç¼ø!æ,Ä�ìkëíúkïrê*�Âý¬øl��ç��#�17 Ñì� /n� ? ÇÈ$ ��� Ù ð �� Që ê('3 v��7Ý� � *�� � ë#�:-c�cëíúkø�g�����~� /| S'núbé!úbçLø�� ? ÇÈ$ ��� Ù ð �§ QëÂê*': z�87Ý� � ��� � ë2��-,�íëíúkø �^�Ì�\�ì�g��� � ­ènÜQâªâ�ß�Ü�a Ù ® � ? ÇÈ$���ñ65iÓð ��íïî � ? ÇÈ$ ��� Ù Óð �Cs` Ý>Þ&Þ�æca Ï ú�çLø�ø!æ,��úz� ? Ç $ ��� Ù Óð �CîOðLé /�çLïnè²-né�ð&)nú�� ? Ç $���ñ65 Óð � �§7 'Óú:-Óé!ð�-Yúké ê]ý�§ë#�Õëcï�� ? ÇË$ �¢ñ65iÓð �Õëíøë#����úkènëíçbê�úQîOé!ð=� � ? ÇÌ$ �¢� Ù Óð � � � ï�ê*'númø!ç���ú� Ìç�ý ç{ø¶Á�ú��:��çw � «�/| Ìú¹ìbçLï�ø0'nð� ürý ænø�ëcï,9:Á�ú"����ç w � y ê('nçUê

��Ñ ��ëcï��" � �g� Õ��s�»���� � �� �   �K � ó ô QëÂê*': n�T���áP � �l�

���

Page 23: 東京工業大学shioura/papers/quadML.pdf! " # $&%(' )+*,' -.)0/.$ 1 $&2 3547698;:&)&= 8@? = 8A)&' ->$CB DFEHG;I>J>KLI>MONQPSRUT>VWV.XYVAZ []\!ZWV>G!^ I>MO_`V>\FPaRb_cNb\aRdN

S'nëíì&',/nê�ð�9Lú¯ê('núbé§ QëÂê*'�� ? Ç $ ��� Ù Óð �l/&ë#��-,�cëíúkø��§ëíëcë#� �Ï úmïnð� -né!ð�)�ú3�§ëíë#� � ãÌø�ø!æ,��ú� n�©�Ã� ��� çLïnè��n� ø!æc-,- Ó �� �� �u Ù ç{ø!ú � òµ n�©���-P � x � îF � �g��� � /0ê('núbïÎ� ? ÇË$ �¢� Ù Óð �Që#�:��úbènëcçUê�ú"� ý�ý�ëcú��cènøÆ�§ëíë2� �0 ê('núbéT Qëíø!ú"/\ �úÆ'nç�)nú� � �^�BÑ � /�çLïnè7ê*'núké�úkîOðLé�ú¹ê('nú3-né!ð�-Yúké ê]ýì� ëcëíë#��øl'nð� Qï çLüYð�)�úë2��-,�íëíúkø� � �g��Ñ �XÑ ��ëíï �Õ�yãóäÕå<å æ �èç � � �g� �u Ù ç{ø!ú � ò, n�©�Ã�·� � x ��æ~ê�ê�ëíï,9X ú �� ¤��7Ý� � Që ê('fç�ø!æ,Ä�ìkëíúkïrê*�Âý øl��ç��#�97 Ñ�� /c Ìú'nç�)�ú� ú �©���»P � /�ø�æ,-,- Ó �K ú ��� ø�æ,-,- Ó �� ��0/Ðç{ïnè¬ø!æc-,- � �� ú ��� ø!æ,-c- � �� �� � É úkïnìbú"/ê('númçLé09Læ,��úkïrê¹ëíï Ù çLø�ú � ë#��-,�cëíúkø

� �^� ��7 �g��� � �K ú � � �g��Ñ ��ëíï�<�cã¹äÕåÕåOæ �èç � �� ú � � �g� � ��ëíï�<�cã¹äÕåÕåOæ � ç � �� � �g� �:7 �g��� ���

S'núké�ú �g�����~�g��� ürývÁ�ú"����ç w �2Å=�µ7 'nëíø»ø0'nð� Qø�� ëcë#� � ­

! su×ls µ "�ø�û(ûXz1ó�ûXz�Ël�l9&û"ør9<�só µ s�¶�;¤÷"üx{ µ s�¶ � q�ú¯úuvènÜQâªâ�ß�Ü�a ÙÎÙ � ? ÇÈ$ ��� Ù �§íïî � ? ÇË$ �¢� Ù ð �Cs` Ý>Þ&Þ�æca � ? ÇÌ$ ��� Ù �îOð{éÕñ�ìbçLïFü�úmé�ú1 Qé!ë ê!êrúkïfçLøÕîOð��#�cð� QøÕëcï�ê�úbél��øÕðLî � ìkî � � w � { �l��ò

�M �� óÈôi���M�;� ø!æ,-,- Ó �K ���� D ��� ø�æ,-,-l�§�K ��x(z� �  mòu � �g� PÍ � �g� x ðLéSu � �g� �� � �g� çLïnè �^�Ì� * �g��� � � �g������� x �

� w � ¥��

S'núké�ú � ��� ® ç{ïnè �g� ��� � � � � � ���:� ����ürý ìkðLï*)�úbïrê�ëíðLï � É úbïnìkú�/zê('núÍ4+�Aî 6ènëíé!úkì¯ê�ëíðLï7ëíøÕðLü*)�ëcðLæÓø �Ï úÕê('núbïz-né�ð�)�ú»ê*'nú�ìbðLï*)�úké�ø!ú � Á�údêA �� ó ô çLïÓè���� ø!æ,-c- Ó �� �� � ½ÎðLéÕçÔø�æ,Ä�ìkëíúkïrê(� ýøl��ç��#�7 Ñ � /aènúbûnïnú=< ��ï ¦* � 7Ý�l�<� � ~>7 � � QëÂê*'�ð��5ø!æ,-c- � �� ��9çLïnèi~:�ÖÕ>ðpÕ ��7 'núbï,/ �úX'nç�)�ú¶��� ø!æ,-,- Ó �?< ��;� ø�æ,-,- Ó �K ��»çLïÓè7ø!æc-,-l�§�?< ��n� ø!æ,-,-l�.�� �� � Ø ý¾� ? ÇÌ$ ��� Ù ð �ç�-,-,�íëíúkè�ê�ð@< ¬çLïnès�l/Óê('núbé!úQú1��ëcø ê�ø��s�¬ø�æ,-,-l�§�?< ��5(�� �  �ø!ænì&'�ê('nçbê

��� < � � �g� � �g� ���ï � � �g� � �^� �A*~� � 7 ���S� � ~A7Ý� � � � � �g� � �g� �l� � w � «��

��æ~ê� ú � � ���B� � � � � � ~¶� � �Õ� � � � î��Ã�� � /aê('núbïv� ? Ç $ ��� Ù ð ��ç=-,-,�íëcúbè�êrðA ú çLïnè��ë2��-,�íëíúkø�� �ú � � �g��� ��ëcï�� � ���� �úV� � �g�   � �K �ú � � �g� � � w � w �

��{

Page 24: 東京工業大学shioura/papers/quadML.pdf! " # $&%(' )+*,' -.)0/.$ 1 $&2 3547698;:&)&= 8@? = 8A)&' ->$CB DFEHG;I>J>KLI>MONQPSRUT>VWV.XYVAZ []\!ZWV>G!^ I>MO_`V>\FPaRb_cNb\aRdN

S'núké�úÌê('nú�ø!úkìbðLïnè�ëíïnúkäaænç��íë ê]ý ëíø�ürý»Á�ú"����ç w �#Å��F¡ ðbê�úê('nçbêÌê('nú�ëíïnúbäSæÓç��cë ê]ý5� w � w �ç��íø!ð:'nð��íènø§ QëÂê*':�s� � ø�ëcïÓìkú3�� ú � � � �A� � �<Ù ð���ünëíïnëíï,9z� w � «��@çLïnè�� w � w �0/| ÌúX'nç�)nú��� � � �g� � �g� �A*:7C�� � ��� � � � � �^� � �g� ���ï � � �g� � �^� �A*:7C� �g��� * �^�©� � � �g��� �l�

ë2��-,� ý�ëcïc9 � w � ¥�� � ­7 'númúkäaænë)(ç��cúbïnìkúQüYúdêU Ìúkúkï�� ? $ ��� Ù �ç{ïnèª� ? $ �¢� Ù ð �@ìbçLïFü�úCø0'nð� Qï�ø�ë2��ë#�cç{él� ý�çLøÁ�ú"����ç w ����� /0ë2��-,� ý�ëcï,9 7 'núkð{é!ú"� { �Ð� ¥�� ëcë#� �Ï úÌènúkïnðUê�úÌürý»� ? ÇÈ$���ñ65 ð ��ê('nú8-Óé!ð�-Yúké ê]ýØ� ? ÇÌ$ ��ñB5iÓð �� QëÂê*'¹ê('Óú�ø§êré!ëíìdêmëíïnúkäaænç=�cë ê�ëíúkø4 Ñ 6 é!ú�-,�cç{ìkúkè�ürý ëíïnúkäaænç=�cë ê�ëíúkø�4 � 6�� Ø ýÎ� { ��� { �»çLïnè 7 'núbðLé!ú�� { ��� ¥²�§ëíë#�l/� Ìús'nç�)�ú4 � Þ Ç íïî � Þ íïî � ? $ ��� Ù ð �¹îOð{é íàî � ? Ç $ ��ñB5 ð �¹îOðLé / 6 S'núké�ú �º� �^�Ì� �·��� ô Ó � ëíøp9Lë)�úbï7ürý�� { �Ð� � � �µ7 ð¼ìbðLïnì��cænèÓúÕê*'núX-Óé!ðSðLîzð{î 7 'núbðLé!ú��{ ��� � /&ë ê¹ø!æ,Ä�ìkúbø�êrð�øl'nð� 4�� ? ÇÈ$���ñB5 ð ��íàî � ? ÇÈ$ ��� Ù ð � �26�7 'nú 4+�Aî 6 ènëíé!úbìdê�ëíðLïëcøQðLü*)�ëcð{ænø ��7 ð�ø0'nð� ê('nú�ìbðLï*)�úké�ø!ú�/�çLø�ø!æ,��úz� ? ÇÈ$ ��� Ù ð �mîOðLé � ½ÎðLéCç{ï�ýDC Ñÿ� / �úQènúbûnïnú FE � *GCn� �C7 'núkï,/�îOðLé§ �� óÈôÔç{ïnè:�n� ø�æ,-,- Ó �K ��§ �úS'nç�)�ú

� �^� *GC� ��Ñ � �^��� �Èëíïp� � � ��ëíï�<�cã¹äÕåÕåOæ � ç � � �g�  � �Èëíïp� � � ��ëíï�<�cã¹äÕåÕåOæ � ç � �� � �g� *GC\ � �l ��

ë � ú � /�� ? ÇÌ$ ��� Ù Óð ��'nð��íènø@îOðLé � ½Yé�ð��ÖÁ9ú����Èç w �Ð� � îOð��2�íð� QøS� ? ÇÈ$���ñ65iÓð ��îOðLé FE îOðLéçLïrýHC Ñ5� /�ë2��-,� ý�ëcïc9�� ? ÇÌ$ ��ñB5 ð �îOð{é �! su×ls � "�ø�û(ûXz�ûXzSËl�l9&û"ør9<�só µ s�¶W¶¤÷"üx{ µ s�¶ �Ï ú¹øl'nð� ê('Óúª4¯ðLï,� ý ëcî 6 -ÓçLé§ê�ðLî 7 'núbðLé!ú�� { ����� ð{ï,�Âý �F7 'Óúª4¯ëíî 6 -nçLé§ê�ðLî 7 'núbðLé!ú��{ ����� ëcøÕúkç{ø§ý�/�çLïÓè 7 'ÓúkðLé�ú"� { ��� «�ìkçLïfüYúQø0'nð� Qï7ø�ë2��ë#�cçLé0�Âý �Ù ðLïnø�ëcènúbé¼ç�äaænçLèÓé!çbêrëcì ? ÇÈ$�ìbðLï*)�ú+�­îOænïnìdêrëcð{ï ñ­ò@ó�ô+õ ó 9Lë>)núkï+ürý � { � ¥��A Që ê(' � Þ Ç �<£ ëíïnìkú¹çLél9���ëíï»ñ ëcøÕçLï ? ÇÈ$�ìkð{ï()nú1�ª�íëcïnúbçLéø!ænünø0-nçLìbú"/�ê('núbé!úQú1��ëcø ê�ø»ç¼ø�ænüt$-nçLé ê�ë ê�ëíðLïz���.�:ÕF~:� � � � �"�*�*�¢� �  ¼ðLîF� ø!ænì&'�ê('nçUê

çLél9·��ëcïñÆ� ø0-nçLï��ò� �M� �W� � ��� � Õ¢�&�0�������= Q(z�W� � Õ��n���T

ò� �M� �.�t ��

ürýG��é�ð�-YðLø!ë ê�ëíðLï � � � �<£ ëíïnìkú³%{úbé �5çLél9·��ëcïñC/i �úS'nç�)�ú

� � I ��� � ��� � ��� �^� I � �^� I � � �KJ��»�3���&�1�������^�1~:��� � � � �*�"�*��� �  ���� � w � ¿��� � I � � � �^� I � � �LJ¤���3���n�»�T

ò� �M� ���t�l�

� ¥

Page 25: 東京工業大学shioura/papers/quadML.pdf! " # $&%(' )+*,' -.)0/.$ 1 $&2 3547698;:&)&= 8@? = 8A)&' ->$CB DFEHG;I>J>KLI>MONQPSRUT>VWV.XYVAZ []\!ZWV>G!^ I>MO_`V>\FPaRb_cNb\aRdN

Ï úènúbûnïnúçX��çbêré!ë� �B�\òåürý � �<ÔC� �g��� �K�;�����=���s����Ôå�.~c�Cöµ��� � � � �*�*�*�¢� �  ��0/ S'nëíì&' ëíø� �ú��2�$�ènúbûnïnúbè ürý5� w � ¿=� �§£ ëíïnìbú ëcøCç¬-né�ëcïnìbë2-Óç���ø!ænüc�ÈçUê�é!ë� ðLî / ç��íø!ðü�ú��cð{ï,9Løêrð Þ Ç � ? ðLé!úbð&)núké0/9ê('Óúþúkäaænçbêrëcð{ï�%{úbé � çLél9·��ëcïñ²ë#��-,�íëcúbøÌê('nçbê ëíøïnðLïnø�ëcïc9Læ,�íçLé � É úkïnìbú"/ �BÞ Ç\'nð��íènø �! su×ls � "�ø�û(ûXz1ó�ûXz�Ël�l9&û"ør9<�só µ s�¶Nײ÷"üx{ µ s�¶ !Ï úp-né!ð�)nú 7 'núkð{é!ú"� { ��� w ðLïc�Âý ��7 'núbðLé!ú�� { �Ð� � ëcøÐë2����úkènëíçbêrú�îOé!ð�� 7 'núbðLé!ú�� { �Ð� w �Ï úmûné�ø§ê¹øl'Óð& ê('nú�4¯ëíî 6 -nç{é§ê �C7 'nú¹îOæÓïnìdêrëcðLï�ñ�ëcøÕé�ú1 Qé!ë ê!êrúkï�çLø

ñ��� ����ò� �M� �� nuË�.� x � uË�.� x nu>��� x �K ���z�l�

É úbïnìkú�/Õê*'nú ? $�ìbðLï*)�ú1��ë ê]ý ðLî¹ñ îOð��2�íð� Qø�ë#����úkènëíçbê�ú��Âý îOé�ð�� u>��� x � Þ ��~ �� � � �"�*�*�¢� � � �Ï úHê*'núkï�-né�ð�)�úùê('nú34]ðLï,� ýÁëíî 6 -nçLé ê �|£ æ,-,-YðLø!úùê*'nçbêñÁëíø ? $�ìbðLï*)�ú1� ��7 'núbï,/�ènð��²ñÃ�� ëcø�çLï ? $�ìbðLï*)�ú+�5�cëíïnúkç{é�ø!ænüÓøl-nçLìbú"/@çLïÓè�ê*'núké�úkîOðLé�ú�� ���" ��,óÈôÎÕ� n�T���=�s�� ��~s� � � � �*�*�*�¢� � �� �îOðLé@ø�ð���úB-nçLé ê�ë ê�ëíðLïÃ�����:ÕF~�� � � � �"�*�*�¢� �  �ðLî.� ürýM��é�ð�-Yð�$ø!ë ê�ëíðLï � � � �Ï úHê*'núkï�-né�ð�)�ú u>��� x � Þ �~s� � � � �"�*�*�¢� � � � Á9ú¯ê� \�0´¬��� üYú�çLïrý�)núkìdêrðLé!øµ Që ê(' I ��´ I � � �KJ¤���ý����^�l/&ç{ïnè��n� ø!æ,-c- Ó �� �� ´C� ý �.� � Ø ýÔê*'nú ? $�ìbðLï*)�ú+�0ë ê]ý ðLîñC/(ê*'núké�ú¹ú+�0ëíø§ê�ø!ð=�Èú���� ø!æ,-,- � �� 3��´C�@çLïÓè

!� Ñ�� ø!çbêrëcø�îgý0ëíï,9

ñ��� ��A* ñ���´�� � ñ��K ¤�!��� � ��� � �0�A*åñ��K´»*

!��� � ��� � �l� ���

!�¹� � � ! � x �l�

� ïª-ÓçLé§êrëcìbæ,�cç{él/C Ìú:'Óç&)núS ��!��� � �Û� � �B�§� çLïn謴ï*

!��� � �V� � �B�Û� îOð{éCçLïrý

!��� � � ! � x /Õë2��-,� ý�ëcï,9��¾�ÿ��� �¶7 'ÓëcøÈîOçLìdê7øl'Óð& Qømê('nçUêÈê*'núfäSæÓçLèné!çUê�ëíì�îOænïÓìdê�ëíðLïñN��òÓó U } õöóR(z�+*1,¹ :9{ë>)núkï7ürý

ñN�c�� �ú ��� �� �� �úV� � u>��� x �ú;�� ú � ó U }_�� ú �©���^��� � �l�*1, �§ðbê*'núkéå Qëcø�ú*�

ëcø ? $}ìkðLï*)nú1��/zë#��-,� ý0ëíï,9 u>��� x � Þ �Ï úÌïnú1�aêmø0'nð� � { � y � � ��æ.ê� ��º�� � � � �Yø ��*@CA��� � � � �ùø �\ Që ê('Áç{ï�ý7é!úbç��0ïaæ,�¹ü�úbéNC·/çLïnès´Æ�ή �C7 'núkï,/·� ? $ ��� Ù �@ç�-c-,�cëíúkè�êrð³ \�1´¬��� çLïnè��n� ø�æ,-,- Ó �K :�v´���ë#�:-c�cëíúkøê('nçUê@ê('núbé!úQú1��ëcø ê�øø!ð���ú

! Ñ � ø!ænì&'�ê('nçUê

��� !� � �g����ø � �g��� � �g�Yø>�Yø �A*

!CA� �g�Yø>� � �g�YøË�ùø � �g��� * �g���Ðø �x*

!ñ � �g��� * �g�YøË�Yø � � �g����ø �l�

� «

Page 26: 東京工業大学shioura/papers/quadML.pdf! " # $&%(' )+*,' -.)0/.$ 1 $&2 3547698;:&)&= 8@? = 8A)&' ->$CB DFEHG;I>J>KLI>MONQPSRUT>VWV.XYVAZ []\!ZWV>G!^ I>MO_`V>\FPaRb_cNb\aRdN

£ ëíïnìkú$CåìbçLï�üYúCì&'nðLø�úkï�ç{é!ünë ê�é�çLé!ë#�Âý�/| ÌúX'nç�)nú �g�YøË� � �g�Yø>�ùø � �g��� * �g���ùø � � �

O áOû0ÛzÞP�:äåÜaßxÿ!ÜQâªÜSÛ0Ü*Þ

7 'núQçLæ~ê('ÓðLé!øùê('ÓçLï,%RQðLëíì&'nëíé!ð 7 ç=%.ç='nçLøl'Óë�îOðLé@ènëíø!ìkæÓø!ø!ëíðLï�ç{ïnè�üÓëcü,�íëíð�9Lé!ç=-,'nëíìQëíïnîOðLéå$��çbê�ëíðLï,/Lç{ïnèmçLïnðLïrý���ðLænø�é!úbîOúké!úbúkø�îOðLé(ê*'núkëíé,)(ç��cæÓçLü,�íú�ìkð�����úkïrê�ø�ðLï�ê*'nú���çLïaænø!ìbé!ë#-~ê �7 'nëíø� �ð{él%Qëcøzø!æ,-,-YðLé ê�úkè�ürý � é�çLïrêl$}ëcït$}ãÌëíè�ðLî.ê('nú ? ëcïnëíø§êré§ýÔðLî � ènænìbçbê�ëíðLï,/ Ù æ,� ê�æné�ú"/£ -YðLé§êrøl/ £ ìbëcúbïnìkúQçLïnè 7 úbì&'nïnð��íð�9bý ð{îS5¢ç�-ÓçLï �

ó ÜQæÐÜaÝgÜSÛ9á�ÜQÞ

T ´VUXW�ÇZY�Ç�[Ð�0ªr��®¯�¯����À]\&�SÊ��0¨!®¯�UÊ����{�U¨�¾�«m��ªr�.¾¿¥ �a½È¨!��ª��S®b¨��;��®B^¥ �a���U¥¿�;�bÀ� ¢�.�;�]°S®¯�`_����]���¥ �@aH¥ �SÊQ¨!�]�a�.Êm¨!�U¥¿�;�`b�Æ�ÀYÄr�S®b¥ �a½���®bÀ9a���®b¾¿¥ ��Àδ�µcd�Ç

T ÅVUXeÇ][Ф{�.¾ �¯�¯����ÀÓÏ;�]��®b¨!�U¥ £��þÄr�S¾ °a�U¥ ��� «Q���]�a�nª��bÀ�\�¨�Ê�±a®b¥¿ªr½���f9��¥ £nÇ�gή¯���¯�bÀh\�¨�Ê�±a®b¥¿ª�½��.À´�µ�µViSÇ

T dVUXjÐÇ�aù¨�¾¿ªa¥¿�lknÀm[ °a��¥ ºa�.ª,¨!�a�a®¯�S¨�� � �]�5�Ó�S¾ ¦{�a�SÊm¥¿¨�¾¿¾ ¦ �d�S¾ £L¨!±�¾ � ��¨!�¯���¬�S�þ¥ �~�]��½���®n �S���a�¯����¨!®b¨!±0¾ �>oÔÑU°�¨�ªr®k¨!�U¥¿����S�U¥¿Êm¥ Ë.¨!�U¥ ����À�W�¥ �b�;®¯���]�p[��a��¾¿ÇH«¼¨!�]�0ÇH¶�´þ³]´�µ�µb�·m´�µb!ÃÅ�´�Å�Ç

T iUq[CÇ�a���®bÊQ¨!��À�jÐÇ�r.Ç�gz¾ �.ÊmÊ����a�kÀ�_9���a�a��½S¨!�U¥ £�� «¼¨!�]®b¥¿�;���©¥ � �]�a� «Ô¨!�]�a�.Êm¨!�U¥¿��¨�¾ÄS��¥ �����;���bÀYÄ��n��¥ ���A¦Á�¸��®�Ï;��ªr°a�d�]®b¥¿¨�¾�¨!��ª=[��a��¾¿¥ �.ª�«Ô¨!�]�a�.Êm¨!�U¥¿�;�kÀsg��0¥¿¾¿¨�ªr�.¾ �a��¥¿¨�Àδ�µ�µViSÇ

T bVUXgnÇutÕÇvWz�U¦�¾ �.Àwr.Ç   Ä��a�.¾¿¾¿ÀxjШ!��ªr�SÊ y ¨�¾ k~� ¨!��ª zz¾ �.�;�]®b¥¿� _����AÉz��®{k~�bÀ\�¨!®¯°a� «Q���a��½�®b¨!�S��À,«Ô¨!�]��Ç�[��¯�¯����Çå�S�|[CÊ���®b¥¿��¨�À}y ¨!�¯��¥ �a½��]��� W~\�À,´�µcVi���{�]�]���*����¸®¯���{�UÇ¿Êm¨!�]��Ç °���ªa¨¯£n¥ �kÇ �.ªr°���Êm¨!�]��Ç*gSj���Æ�Æ�Æ�´�Æb�

T ¶VUXgnÇ/�a¨]£¢¨!�U¥¿À��&Ç��0¨!®bªr�.¾¿¾¿¨�À�\����~£���¤�¥ �§¦å¥ � �a����¾¿¥ �S�.¨!®Ô¥ �{�]��½���®��S®¯��½�®b¨�ÊmÊm¥ �S½SÀ�j�¥¿�;��®b��¨e��Ó��®k¨!�U¥ £L¨`bdQ³]´�µ�µ�Æ�·/d!ÃiiSÇ

T �VUq[CÇ.�r®k¨!�.knÀ�[��¼¨�¾ ½���®b¥ �]�0Ê­�¸��®��¯°a±�Ê���ªr°�¾¿¨!®��¸°a���;�U¥ ���a�9���m½�®b¨!�a�a�kÀ�[��a��¨�¾ �9�S�PW�¥ �b�;®¯���]�«Ô¨!�]�a�.Êm¨!�U¥¿�;�m´�¶m³]´�µc�Å�·�µ�!ÃS´�Å�Æ�Ç

T cVU5ÄSÇ���°aÍ ¥ �d��¥ ½��.À�Är°a±�Ê@�nªr°0¾¿¨!®��r°a�0�;�U¥ ���a�²¨!��ª�eù�a�U¥¿ÊQ¥ Ë.¨!�U¥ ����À�[Ð�S��¨�¾ ���S��W�¥ �b�;®¯���]�«Ô¨!�]�a�.Êm¨!�U¥¿�;�~i���À1_9��®¯�]�a¡{Y9�S¾¿¾¿¨!��ªaÀ.[�Ê@�¯�]��®bªa¨�ÊmÀ�´�µ�µ�´�Ç

T µVU5ÄSÇ��r°aÍ]¥ �¯��¥ ½��.À�^ÕÇH«m°S®¯���U¨�ÀS_9���]�������¬ a¡{��«m¡d�;���{£���¤ �°a�0�;�U¥ ���a��¨!�0ª��]�a���¯����¨!®b¨!�U¥ ����]�S����®¯�.Ê��bÀΫԨ!�]��Ç1gή¯��½�®b¨�ÊmÊQ¥ �a½�ccm³]Å�Æ�Æ�Æ�·�´�Å�µ!ÃS´ViS¶�Ç

T ´�ÆVU�«ÔÇ.�r°�k~°a�d��¥¿Êm¨�À��CÇ�eù�¯��¥¿Êm¨�À¢«ÔÇ¢�0¨Vk��.ªa¨�À�W�¥ ®b¥¿� ��¾ ���/�r��®bÊ@��¨!��ªCÄr¦�ÊmÊ����]®k¥¿��«¼¨!®�k��b£gή¯���;���¯�¯���bÀ�y ¨�¾ �]��®Cªr�Rt�®¯°a¦{�]��®bÀZa���®b¾¿¥ ��Àδ�µ�µViSÇ

T ´�´VU��&Ç�tù®b¨!�a���UÀ�r.Ç0Ä�k���®b¥ �S¡{^Õ¨!�n�U£�À�[CÇ��0¨�Êm¥ ®bÀ�f��k¥ �a½ÔÑU°�¨�ªr®b¨!�U¥¿���a®¯��½�®k¨�ÊmÊm¥ �a½¹�]�¹�¯�S¾ £���0¥ ½��åÊ�°�¾ �U¥ ��¾¿¥¿��¥ �A¦ �b� �a�.ªr°�¾¿¥ �a½��a®¯��±�¾ �.Ê@�¹��� ��¨!®b¨�¾¿¾ �.¾�Êm¨��O�0¥ �a���bÀ�[�¾ ½���®b¥ �]�0Êm¥¿��¨�´�³]´�µ�µ��·�´�Æ�Æ!ÃS´�´�Æ�Ç

��w

Page 27: 東京工業大学shioura/papers/quadML.pdf! " # $&%(' )+*,' -.)0/.$ 1 $&2 3547698;:&)&= 8@? = 8A)&' ->$CB DFEHG;I>J>KLI>MONQPSRUT>VWV.XYVAZ []\!ZWV>G!^ I>MO_`V>\FPaRb_cNb\aRdN

T ´�ÅVU�W�Ç¿ÄaÇ�Y����O�{±�¨!°�ÊmÀ�ÄaÇ ¡{gnÇ�Y����S½SÀh[бn��°a���¯�]®d���a½S¾ ¦��Ó�S¾ ¦{�a�SÊm¥¿¨�¾��U¥¿Ê���¨�¾ ½���®b¥ �]��Ê@�Ô�¸��®ÑU°�¨�ªr®k¨!�U¥¿�����a�U¥¿Êm¥ Ë.¨!�U¥ ��� �U£���®��¯°a±�Ê@�nªr°0¾¿¨!®��;���S�¯�]®b¨�¥ �{�]�bÀ�«Ô¨!�]��Ç�g�®d��½�®b¨�ÊmÊm¥ �a½ ¶�µ³]´�µ�µb�·�Å�¶�µ!Ã�d�Æ�µ�Ç

T ´dVU�W�Ç¿ÄaÇ�Y����O�{±�¨!°�ÊmÀ�jÐÇ¢Är��¨�Êm¥ ®kÀ�r.Ç*tÕÇ¢Är�0¨!�~�]��¥ k{°�Êm¨!®kÀ�[¬�n�S¾ ¦{�a�SÊm¥¿¨�¾¢¨�¾ ½���®b¥ �]��Ê5�Â��®�¨!�¥ �{�]��½���®ÈÑU°�¨�ªr®b¨!�U¥¿��a���a¡O�¯���0¨!®b¨!±�¾ �Q�]®k¨!�a�¯�n��®¯�U¨!�U¥ �����a®¯��±�¾ �.ÊQÀ�«¼¨!�]�0Ç�gή¯��½�®b¨�ÊmÊQ¥ �a½bb¹³]´�µ�µ�Å�·�db�µ!Ã�d��´�Ç

T ´ViU�W�Ç¿ÄaÇ2Y9���O�{±�¨!°�ÊmÀ=r.Ç*tÇCÄr��¨!�{�]��¥ k~°0Êm¨!®bÀ�\&���~£���¤ �¯����¨!®k¨!±�¾ �����a�U¥¿Êm¥ Ë.¨!�U¥ ��� ¥ �Á�S���Ê�°�� �È��¨!®bª���®��]��¨!��¾¿¥ �a�.¨!®Ð���a�U¥¿Êm¥ Ë.¨!�U¥ ����À�r.Ç�[6\�«�d�m³]´�µ�µ�Æ�·FcVi�d!Ã�c�¶�Å�Ç

T ´bVU� �ÇY a�U£F�¨!�¯Ë.À&Är°a±�Ê���ªr°�¾¿¨!®�¸°a���;�U¥ ���S�̨!��ª¼�;���~£���¤�¥ �§¦.À�¥ ���.[�Ç�aù¨��O�a�.ÊmÀ&«ÔÇstù®�����]�b�O�a�.¾¿ÀaùÇ�^���®¯�]�.À��.ªr�kÇ¿À�«¼¨!�]�a�.ÊQ¨!�U¥¿��¨�¾Fgή¯��½�®b¨�ÊmÊQ¥ �a½���]�a��Ä��U¨!�]���S�z�]�a��[�®¯�UÀ�Är�a®k¥ �a½���®bÀa���®b¾¿¥ �0Àδ�µcd�À�Ådb!ÃSÅb��Ç

T ´�¶VU�aùÇ¢ �Ç{«Ô¥¿¾¿¾ ��®bÀ�eù��Êm¥ �0¥¿Êm¥ Ë.¥ �a½@�a���a�d����¨!®b¨!±�¾ �@�°S���;�U¥ ���a��ªr��ºa�S�.ª����C�]�S�@¥ �{�]��½���®¯��ÉÌ¥ �]�¨!��¥ �~£����{�]��®¯¦F¨!�a��¾¿¥¿��¨!�U¥ ���0ÀYÄrÏ�[�«�r.Ç�[Ð�a�0¾¿Ç�«¼¨!�]��ÇYÅ�´m³]´�µ��´�·Ð´�¶�¶!ÃS´cb�Ç

T ´�VU�^Ça«m°S®¯���U¨�À�\&���{£���¤�¥ �§¦È¨!��ªmÄ��]�.¥ ��¥ �]Ë>� �z��¤��O�0¨!�a½����a®d���Ó��®d�§¦.À�[Cªr£�Ça«¼¨!�]�0Ça´�ÅVi�³]´�µ�µ�¶�·Å��Å!Ã�d�´�´�Ç

T ´cVU�^ÇΫm°S®¯���U¨�À1W�¥ �b�;®¯���]���;���~£���¤f¨!��¨�¾ ¦{�b¥ �bÀY«¼¨!�]��Çsg�®¯��½�®b¨�ÊQÊm¥ �a½�cdm³]´�µ�µc�·Fd�´d!Ã�d��´�ÇT ´�µVU�^Ç�«m°a®d���U¨�ÀpW�¥ �k�;®¯���]�|\&���{£���¤|[Ð��¨�¾ ¦{�b¥ �bÀ�Ä��n��¥ ���A¦ �¸��®�Ï;��ªr°a�¯�]®k¥¿¨�¾�¨!�0ª�[Ð�a�0¾¿¥ �.ª

«Ô¨!�]�a�.Êm¨!�U¥¿�;�kÀ�gÎ��¥¿¾¿¨�ªr�.¾ �a��¥¿¨�ÀYÅ�Æ�Æd�ÇT Å�ÆVU�^Ç «Q°a®¯���U¨�ÀH[CÇ�Är�0¥ ��°a®b¨�À�«Q¡d�;���~£���¤ �°a�0�;�U¥ ��� ��� ½����a��®b¨�¾¿¥ Ë��.ª �Ó�S¾ ¦�Êm¨!�]®¯�S¥¿ªSÀ

«Ô¨!�]��Ç�eù�n��®bÇ9j����bÇÎÅViÔ³]´�µ�µ�µ�·Ðµb!ÃS´�Æb�ÇT Å�´VU�^Ç.«Q°a®¯���U¨�À�[�Ç~Är��¥ ��°a®k¨�À>z�¤{�]���a�b¥ ���Ì�S�¢«Q¡d�;���~£���¤�¥ �§¦�¨!��ª» ¢¡d�;���{£���¤n¥ �A¦»�]���n�S¾ ¦~�a�.ª�®b¨�¾

�;���{£���¤f�¸°a���;�U¥ ���a�bÀ�[�ªr£�Ç�[��a��¾¿Ç�«Ô¨!�]��ÇÎÅbm³]Å�Æ�Æ�Æ�·Fdb�Å!ÃiSÅ��ÇT Å�ÅVU�^Ç.«Q°a®¯���U¨�À�[�Ç~Är��¥ ��°a®b¨�À>\&���aÍ`°a½S¨��;¦@®¯�.¾¿¨!�U¥ ���a�¯�0¥ �»±n���§ÉH������«m¡d�;���{£���¤�¨!��ª» ¢¡d�;���{£���¤

�¸°a���;�U¥ ���S�»¥ ���;���{�U¥ �~°a��°S��£¢¨!®b¥¿¨!±�¾ ���bÀ�«¼¨!�]��Çsg�®¯��½�®b¨�ÊQÊm¥ �a½È³]Å�Æ�Æd�·]ÀS�]�Ô¨!�a�n�.¨!®bÇT ÅdVU�Y�Ç�_�¥ kL¨�¥¿ªr�SÀ¢ �¥ �a�.¨!®�[C¾ ½���±a®b¨��Â��®�zz�;���a�SÊm¥¿�;�bÀ�aù¨�¥¿�¸°.k¢¨!��ÀL�a�k{¦��SÀa´�µ�¶�´�Ç T Ï;��r.¨!��¨!�a���d��UT ÅViU�jÐÇÎ��ÇZj��n�lkL¨��¸�.¾¿¾¿¨!®bÀ�\&���~£���¤�[���¨�¾ ¦{�b¥ �bÀ1gήb¥ ���;���]���#f9��¥ £�Ç1g�®¯���d�bÀZg�®b¥ �0�;���]����Àδ�µ��Æ�ÇT ÅbVU�jÐÇ9��ÇSj����&k¢¨��Â�.¾¿¾¿¨!®kÀ�_9���§ÉH��®�k:�&¾ �bÉ���¨!��ªf«Q���a���]®¯����¥¿��eù�a�U¥¿ÊQ¥ Ë.¨!�U¥ ����À�y奿¾ ��¦.À�_���É

����®{knÀ�´�µcViSÇT Å�¶VU�W�Ç�W�Ç��Äa¥¿¾ Í]¨VknÀù �¨!®¯½���¡dÄa��¨�¾ �#Wz¦{��¨�Êm¥¿��Är¦{�¯�]�.Ê���� Är�U¨!±�¥¿¾¿¥ �§¦ ¨!��ª�Är�]®¯°0�;�]°a®¯�.À�_���®¯�]�S¡

Y9�S¾¿¾¿¨!��ªaÀ�_���É�����®�knÀY´�µ�c�ÇT Å�VU�r~ÇmÄr�]�{��®bÀ2\�ÇFy ¥ �]Ë�½S¨�¾¿¾¿À�\&���~£���¤�¥ �§¦,¨!�0ª�eù�a�U¥¿Êm¥ Ë.¨!�U¥ ��� ¥ � �&¥ ��¥ �]��W�¥¿Ê����S�b¥ ���­Ï�À

Ä��a®b¥ �a½���®bÀZa���®b¾¿¥ �0Àδ�µ��Æ�ÇT ÅcVU�jÐÇÎÄaÇ�¡�¨!®¯½S¨�À�«¼¨!�]®k¥ ¤�Ï;�]��®b¨!�U¥ £���[Ð�0¨�¾ ¦~�b¥ �kÀÎÅ!��ªÌ�.ªaÇ¿ÀÎÄ��a®b¥ �a½���®bÀZa���®b¾¿¥ �0À�Å�Æ�Æ�Æ�Ç

� ¿


Recommended